NFL.com rates Smitty as one of the best WR's in the game.

[Cat'sGrowl]

It's done via a grouping system, with Group A being the best, Group B being the 2nd best, and so on..

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/09000d5d82036e05/article/grab-bag-games-best-wrs-ride-firstround-pedigree?module=HP_spotlight

I personally would've put Smitty in Group C, but Smitty is still ahead of some pretty big names on the list. It's a pretty fair list all in all.

Shame how much the poor passing game we have had in Carolina has hurt Smitty's rep as a dominant WR.

[4Corners]

This shouldn't be a surprise to anyone. Smith IS one of the best WR in the game when he doesn't have a retard throwing to him.

#17 to #89 was one of the best combos in the league the past 10 years.

[Doyle]

That list is a bunch of horsesh*t and not because of where Smith is placed.

[Cat'sGrowl]

That list is a bunch of horsesh*t and not because of where Smith is placed.

I'm almost positive this is where I'm supposed to place a "u mad bro" image.

There. Done.

[GritsRgreat]

I think Santana Moss is very underrated.

[4Corners]

[4Corners]

I think Santana Moss is very underrated.

and old.

[Panthro]

This shouldn't be a surprise to anyone. Smith IS one of the best WR in the game when he doesn't have a retard throwing to him.

#17 to #89 was one of the best combos in the league the past 10 years.

Who would you rank ahead and behind them?

[SCMunnerlyn1]

. Roddy White, Falcons (^): Has 200 receptions and 21 touchdowns.

Group A = hell no .. thats a case of only being decent because you're the only receiver being thrown to , he was above average his whole career and he has 1 great year and now hes the 5th best in the game .. bull

4. A.J. Green, Bengals (^): Although he hasn't played a down in the NFL, the talent is obvious. It all depends on who the QB is in Cincinnati.

5. Julio Jones, Falcons (^): He's going into the perfect situation: a tremendous quarterback and Roddy White on the opposite side. Jones will see single coverage all year long and should put up some impressive numbers as a rookie.

Once again Bull they are above 15 other receivers that have played a down of football , and you can say they have talent , ( dwayne jarrett had talent too) but you can't rank someone that has done nothing. /rant

[SCMunnerlyn1]

Who would you rank ahead and behind them?

Manning to Harrison and Culpepper/Brady to moss .. can't think of any others atm

[Razzy]

My coworker, a Chargers diehard, was talking about the rumors that Smitty make come to my hometown team if he leaves the Panthers. I would love to see 89 play for the Chargers if he won't stay. I don't know how successful he would be, but man he was amazing in the past.

You could fill a good 30 minutes with nothing but insane highlights from his career.

[Panthro]

Manning to Harrison and Culpepper/Brady to moss .. can't think of any others atm

I'd say these guys should probably be considered tied or better

Warner - Fitzgerald

Schaub - Johnson

Warner - Holt

Rodgers -Jennings

Manning - Wayne

Palmer - Johnson

Roth- Holmes

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

http://blogs.nfl.com/2011/06/06/a-few-minutes-with-ronde-barber/

Ronde ranked him as the 2nd best receiver in the game.

[panthers55]

Seriously how do guys who have never played a down in the NFL make the list of best receivers in the game. I could see it if this were a list of who could have a big year this season, but to rank any rookies on this list is ridiculous.