Which Defensive Unit are you More Confident In? (CB vs S)

[OnlyPantherFaninMaine]

The corners on our roster currently include: Antoine Cason, James Dockery, De'Quan Menzie, Josh Norman, De'Andre Presley, Josh Thomas, and Melvin White.

 

The safeties on our roster currently include: Thomas DeCoud, Charles Godfrey, Roman Harper, Colin Jones, Robert Lester, and Russell Anderson. 

[panthers90]

If Godfrey's nickel then CB. If he's safety, then the safety group is better.

Sent from my XT1060 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

I'd have to agree with Panthers90.

[OnlyPantherFaninMaine]

Consider Godfrey as a Safety for this thread's purposes as he has yet to play corner thus far for us. 

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

Consider Godfrey as a Safety for this thread's purposes as he has yet to play corner thus far for us.

Then safety...

SS: Roman Harper, Robert Lester, Colin Jones

FS: Thomas DeCoud, Charles Godfrey

Plus we have Anderson Russell, who would be a great guy to keep on the PS (if he's still eligible).

[The Huddler]

I'm thinking safety.

Some hate the harper signing, but I'm confident we can use his strengths and not expose his weaknesses.

CB I am confident in as well. I have a feeling cason will play really well getting with Rivera and Wilks.

Last year we seemed to have had a shakey secondary going into the season, but we finished with a #2 defense. I could see our defense be the undisputed #1 this season.

[Lemory]

Safety. I have a ton of confidence in White and Cason but with Harper and DeCoud, safety has the edge. Oh and I don't think it matters how you classify Godfrey, he gone.

[El Chingon]

Prob safety.

[Panthers8969]

If Godfrey's nickel then CB. If he's safety, then the safety group is better.

Sent from my XT1060 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

So basically Godfrey wherever Godfrey goes that side will be superior? Idk if he will be good this yr coming off the injury. And he hasn't played cb in yrs why do you think he will be a good nickel? Not trying to argue just actually curious.

[Ken]

Safety for sure.

Adding a CB draft is a must IMO.

[R0CKnR0LLA]

pretty comparable IMO

[rayzor]

forced to choose, i'd go with safety.  i don't feel that great about either one, but i think that with that front 7,  that we'll still be in decent shape. i think that safety is pretty much back to the level it was last year heading into the season. CB has a way to go before it gets us back to level. we need at least one more talented guy brought in. i'm not a big fan of keeping godfrey  mainly because of his price tag and the fact he's not a good safety, but i have always thought that CB is his more natural position and that he'd be pretty good there. if they move him to nickel, i'd feel better about CB, but my opinion of the safety group wouldn't change.  the safety corps wouldn't be any weaker if he wasn't there.

[GotSwag?]

Safeties. Sure, Harper and DeCoud are coming off bad seasons, and that's why they signed here for cheap...but they both were recent pro bowl safeties on winning teams. Add in Lester and potentially Godfrey and it's a unit im very confident in.

I don't think our corners are as bad we seem to think. Cason will prove to be a great addition while white will only get better. Thomas, Norman and dockery all have shown signs but were way too.inconsistent.

Sent from my DROID4 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[WolfpackRob]

CB

I actually like our corners. Never a captain fan so replacing him is not a big deal. Cason is the new version of the veteran corner that has past experience with Rivera. Dockery can play. White, Norman, etc., are all tall and should get better this year. In short I think we will be better at corner this year than last.

At safety we have taken a step back. I would have rather had Mike Mitchell than either guy we signed. Godfrey wasn't special before the Achilles and he won't be 100% when the season starts. Lester should improve though. I'll need to see Godfrey play corner at a high level post Achilles with my own eyes in order to believe it.