Greatest QB of all time?

[Jackofalltrades]

I'm more confused by the fact that Russell Wilson is up there.

No kidding. He was a game manager behind a great D.

[NFLFangirl19]

http://www.nfl.com/qs/bracketology/round1.jsp

ok does anyone here believe Phillip Rivers is better than Cam Newton? Im not Saying Cam should be on the list.. but seriously.. Phillip rivers?

he has shown & proven he is one of the best. Cam still has time to do the same but hasn't yet. How this is even a ? Idk.

[DecrypticShadow]

Greatest QB of all time... Hands down, Ryan Leaf.

 

 

That dude is still entertaining as hell to this day.. 

[jasonluckydog]

If Jake Delhomme is not on that list then you can suck my balls.

[BigSyke]

marino and others. dont care to go in detail though...its redundant.

[Guest Dark Knight]

Dan Marino or Joe Montana, depending on your definition of greatest.

Peyton Manning or Tom Brady, according to the media.

[stirs]

Fran Tarkenton..

 

Why they put any guy on the list that has been in the league for only 3 years is beyond me

[ajax4132]

http://www.nfl.com/qs/bracketology/round1.jsp

ok does anyone here believe Phillip Rivers is better than Cam Newton?  Im not Saying Cam should be on the list.. but seriously.. Phillip rivers? 

Phil is a top 5 qb, Cam is top 10

 

Yes Phil is better, RIGHT NOW

 

Things change very quickly though

[ajax4132]

Dan Marino or Joe Montana, depending on your definition of greatest.

Peyton Manning or Tom Brady, according to the media.

Marino and Montana are 1 and 2

 

I think Rodgers could be up there at the end of his career

[LinvilleGorge]

Tough to rank guys who are only a few years into their career. You can talk about guys like Manning, Brees, Brady etc. who are near the tail end of their careers, but pretty much anyone under 30 just doesn't have a long enough resume to be in the discussion.

[Doyle]

I think Marino was the greatest passer of all time.  Montana a more well rounded QB.

[Guest Dark Knight]

I think Marino was the greatest passer of all time. Montana a more well rounded QB.

Nobody can touch Marino from a talent standpoint, IMO.

However, Montana was 4-0 in the Super Bowl & had like 15-17 TD & no turnovers. Ridiculous.

They are in a class all by themselves.

[nickzz]

lol brady vs eli

 

 

pats fans are real mad right now

[Davidson Deac II]

http://www.nfl.com/qs/bracketology/round1.jsp

ok does anyone here believe Phillip Rivers is better than Cam Newton?  Im not Saying Cam should be on the list.. but seriously.. Phillip rivers? 

 

At this point in their careers, yes.  After both are finished, who knows. 

 

Now I am not sure Eli Manning or Russel Wilson belong on that list.  I think they put to much emphasis on a team accomplishment, ie winning superbowls.