PFF Roster Breakdown

[mav1234]

Made a Huddle-friendly version:

 

 

I like our #2 need.

[Catalyst]

PFF relies on pure metrics too much, IMO. For example, they don't take into account how much better Luke makes the defense as a whole. We saw in 2012 how much the defense improved after he took over at MLB. It was almost immediate when Beason went down and Luke took over his spot. You can't account for that with PFF's rating system.

 

And also, they don't seem to take the effect of scheme into effect. Our DB's last year were better than they realistically had any right being. That's not just the front 7, it's also the scheme we're playing. You can't always factor that into these sort of ratings.

[BigCat]

Updated this in Photoshop to account for new additions:

The only part of this starting team that scares me is the offensive line.

[Panthers8969]

Made a Huddle-friendly version:

[/quote

]

You don't think Tolbert is elite? Out of everyone on the roster he is the one dude who has the best argument to be elite at his position. He is the best fb in the nfl rn. Well kuechly might have a better argument bc he won dpoy, but it's close

[Jackofalltrades]

Tolbert is elite at getting in the end zone, but he's not a very good lead blocker, this I think the ranking is fair.

[Mr Mojo Risin]

PFF relies on pure metrics too much, IMO. For example, they don't take into account how much better Luke makes the defense as a whole. We saw in 2012 how much the defense improved after he took over at MLB. It was almost immediate when Beason went down and Luke took over his spot. You can't account for that with PFF's rating system.

And also, they don't seem to take the effect of scheme into effect. Our DB's last year were better than they realistically had any right being. That's not just the front 7, it's also the scheme we're playing. You can't always factor that into these sort of ratings.

You're right luke wins most of his battles before the ball is hiked which is why he is so incredible and why he won DPOY in only his 2nd year in the league and first full year where he was slotted to start at MLB in the offseason whereas his rookie year he also had to learn how to play OLB you'd think PFF would know these things

And star lotulelei and kawaan short both have the same impact on our team as cam? Get out of here with that bull poo (this is directed at PFF not you, Catalyst)

[OneBadCat]

Thomas Davis is a elite as fug. As is Keuchly. Fuggin haters.