Still loving Gettleman?

[unicar15]

This is how teams like the Giants, Steelers, and Patriots have been operating for years. They have the majority of Super Bowls over the last decade...do they not?

[stirs]

I would almost bet that if the following scenario was posed:

 

If I could guarantee a Super Bowl win, would you give up Cam or Keek?

 

Most on the Huddle would stick with the player over the wins and Super Bowl

[cbully]

at the end of the day one must ask, how many superbowl trips did those players take us to?

[cbully]

and btw, "stahr set the bahr"

[TheRed]

To think, all this time all we needed to do to get a Lombardi trophy was give up one of our best players.

Thanks for that insight stirs.

[heel31ok]

Where is this crowd?

silenced.

[csx]

I would give both of them up.

[TheRed]

I think there are a number of people who would give up far more than one of our players for a Super Bowl victory.

While we're at it, let's list off some other impossible scenarios that might get us a Lombardi trophy.

[top dawg]

Not really about giving up a player, it's about giving up private information before you talk to the player.  Regardless what anyone says, that's not a good look, plain and simple.

[heel31ok]

at the end of the day one must ask, how many superbowl trips did those players take us to?

that really means nothing at all unless you want to fire the whole team every year we don't go to a SB.

[TheRed]

Let's just dump everyone, and get an entirely new roster every year because we didn't win the Super Bowl. Good plan?

[heel31ok]

Not really about giving up a player, it's about giving up private information before you talk to the player.  Regardless what anyone says, that's not a good look, plain and simple.

that is correct, but that is also part of the learning process for G-man. I don't think he is as cold as people make him out to be but if he is as smart as they say then he will learn from his mistakes quickly.

[CarolinaCoolin]

So apparently simply asking that a GM personally speak to a player about an important matter like two adults, and not through the media, equates to literally wanting the GM to be just like Marty Hurney. You learn something new everyday.

Apparently becoming a member to this site means you've just become a fan of the panthers. That's a completely ignorant thing to say. Stop trolling

[PhillyB]

yes