Give Richie Incognito a shot?

[Khaki Lackey]

Why not? what do we have to lose?

Our good team chemistry, respect from minority players, repect from the fans, what little respect the media has for us....

[Brooklyn Bully]

Dude acts like he's 18. No thanks. 

[rscott94]

Hell no, dude had a bad rep way before this.

Voted dirtiest player in the league pretty consistently.. I'd pass as well

[rayzor]

this is the last incognito thread, btw.

 

guy doesn't deserve near the attention he gets.

[BeasonBeastingBacks]

nope

[Jangler]

[El Chingon]

I don't think Jerry Richardson and Dave Gettleman would be happy with all the media attention that a Richie Incognito signing would bring. 

[t96]

I wouldn't like the negative press it would bring and I don't think he'd come cheap. If he would I suppose it couldn't really hurt, but I'd prefer we don't get him. We really don't need much help on o-line we'll be getting a lot of guys back from injury.

[Mr. Scot]

If he would I suppose it couldn't really hurt...

It most definitely could, and quite a bit...

[intangiblejohnny]

It most definitely could, and quite a bit...

Wow, Mr. Scot you really hate this, huh?

[Mr. Scot]

"Nasty" makes meathead fans feel all pumped up, but that's about all it's good for.

 

People thinking that being an a--hole off the field means a good offensive lineman on the field are basically showing they're clueless.

 

Ryan Kalil, regularly called the best center in the league, zero off field incidents or anger management issues...

 

Jordan Gross, our best blocker for a lot of his career, zero off field incidents or anger management issues...

 

Travelle Wharton, also part of some of our better OL units, zero off field incidents or anger management issues...

 

Amini Silatolu, a player many draft analysts referred to as having a 'mean streak, zero off field incidents or anger management issues...

 

And some other names to consider...

 

Anthony Munoz, considered by many to be the best offensive lineman ever...

 

Jonathan Ogden, also one of the best tackles of all time...

 

Tony Boselli, first player ever selected by the Jaguars, and still one of the best...

 

Joe Thomas, arguably the best left tackle in the league right now...

 

Larry Allen, who some said was the best player on the Cowboys, not just the best lineman....

 

Jackie Slater, Bruce Matthews, Panthers Assistant OL Coach Ray Brown, all guys who played OL for 20 years, and played well...

 

 

These are some of the most dominating blockers either all time or currently in the league, and all had reputations for being good guys.  And truthfully this is a small list.  There are plenty more names that would fit in the same mold.

 

So...

 

i don't care how good he is (which ain't much), you don't want that steaming pile of poo anywhere near your lockerroom. i'd feel pretty good in saying the rest of the team wouldn't want that here, either.

 

and he wouldn't help much, if at all.

 

Yeah, pretty much.

[Mr. Scot]

Wow, Mr. Scot you really hate this, huh?

 

O-Line is kind of my thing :lol:

 

To the folks supporting this idea, I'd say this. Someone would be given the duty of going to Cam Newton, Steve Smith, Mike Tolbert, Travelle Wharton and others with this little piece of news:

 

"Hey, you know that guy you heard about last season who left the racist voice mails on a teammate's phone, the same guy who got caught on video dropping the N-word while he was going ape s--t in a bar and who's had numerous other incidents prior to that?"

 

"Yeah, well we decided it'd be a good idea to sign him here.  He's on the team now and he's gonna be around you in the locker room all the time.  Any questions?"

 

If you seriously think this is such a great idea, do the team a favor.  Volunteer for that job :unsure:

[intangiblejohnny]

O-Line is kind of my thing :lol:

To the folks supporting this idea, I'd say this. Someone would be given the duty of going to Cam Newton, Steve Smith, Mike Tolbert, Travelle Wharton and others with this little piece of news:

"Hey, you know that guy you heard about last season who left the racist voice mails on a teammate's phone, the same guy who got caught on video dropping the N-word while he was going ape s--t in a bar and who's had numerous other incidents prior to that?"

"Yeah, well we decided it'd be a good idea to sign him here. He's on the team now and he's gonna be around youin the locker room all the time. Any questions?"

If you seriously think this is such a great idea, do the team a favor. Volunteer for that job :unsure:

Good point!

[R0CKnR0LLA]

he's not even that good anymore, he was playing like crap last season before everything happened and he got suspended

 

just re-sign wharton + amini back healthy, that's solid