Replace Cam with any other playoff QB - Do we win 12 games?

[Evengelion]

Andrew luck hardly has talent around him does he? Wayne was out most of the season so he had Hilton and fleener that's equates to smitty and olsen, still has better record than cam first two seasons. Not bashing cam but just saying luck has impressed me more than any other qb of late

jaquars, titans, texans = 6 give-me wins. Enough said. 3 teams that will be selecting top 10 and 2 of them will be selecting top 5. We're talking about QBs with real talent. Enough of this joke.

 

7 INTs in 2 playoff games. Goddayuum!

 

There you go trolling with with Luck cliche here. I'm sure in Redskins land there is poster just like you posting the same cliche on their board as well. Nobody's buying what you're selling. Come back with a new strategy. Your campaign is failing.

[Evengelion]

Lol. Peyton Manning makes weapons out of WRs, not the other way around.

I think he is the best QB in history. Although Joe Montana I would not argue very hard against.

Brady has the rings, but I would still take Manning. I think rings are important but not the only criteria.

Reggie Wayne HOFer.

Pierre Garcon, Redskins' #1 WR and had over 100 catches this year.

Marvin Harrison, just plain filthy. Catches everything.

 

You don't need to undermine those great players to make Peyton look good. Peyton have been in position to just walk 2 yards and pick up a 1st down to keep the drive going instead throw an in-completion and get bounce out of the playoffs. Think about that.

[Evengelion]

Guys, I love Cam to death, but hes benefiting from an amazing defense 

No, the offense controlled the clock. They a good defense but not that great. They're not seattle great.  They couldn't stop NE at all. I think both offense had about 6 possessions. The offense put up a lot of points against many bad teams. Yes the D made some stops but the offense didn't punt that much either. Think about that!

[IGSaint]

Manning would make LaFell a 700 yard receiver

 

So around the number he is this year and last year? Lafell had 677 yards with cam last year.     

[Rook35200]

The only players we win 12 games with are Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Aaron Rogers, Cam Newton, and Possibly Drew Brees. I believe if Cam Newton played for the 49ers since 2011, they would be on their way to their 3rd Super Bowl

[MedellinHeel]

Why do you guys put Wilson in a class with Cam? I know he has overachieved and his story is nice and he seems like a good player and all, but dude is an average at best QB. He hasn't proven anything and they only win due to having Beast Mode and a nasty defense. The idea that he was long considered #2 in the MVP race wasn't laughable but downright embarassing to the sport. To answer OP's question, Manning, Brady, and Rodgers could. Nobody else

 

Go watch our game against SEA and that should answer your question. Wilson makes play after play with his legs and arm running for his life. The same stuff he did in college. He is a gamer no question and more than a game manager. He has a great feel for the game. 

[CPF4LIFE]

Wilson threw for 100 yds last week and Seattle won by 2 scores. He has done that a couple times this season. They won't win a Superbowl like that and we don't win 12 games with him.

[frash.exe]

So around the number he is this year and last year? Lafell had 677 yards with cam last year.

The implication is that LaFell would barely produce more