Replace Cam with any other playoff QB - Do we win 12 games?

[IGSaint]

Peyton Manning played behind some horrendous offensive lines in Indy with no run game to speak of and won 12 games consistently.........

 

Who was peyton manning throwing to when he was with the colts? You realize that matters right?

[stirs]

If it were not for Cams legs, our win total would have suffered greatly.

 

He can throw the ball through a brick wall, but his consistency and touch are still works in progress, along with a couple intangables.  He made great strides this season however

[jptaylor84]

Andrew luck hardly has talent around him does he? Wayne was out most of the season so he had Hilton and fleener that's equates to smitty and olsen, still has better record than cam first two seasons. Not bashing cam but just saying luck has impressed me more than any other qb of late

[AceBoogie]

To be honest the only qb that probably could would be Tom Brady

 

and maybe MAYBE Aaron Rodgers

 

Manning is a tad overrated, played with hall of famers his entire career

fify

[teeray]

Lol. Peyton Manning makes weapons out of WRs, not the other way around.

I think he is the best QB in history. Although Joe Montana I would not argue very hard against.

Brady has the rings, but I would still take Manning. I think rings are important but not the only criteria.

[teeray]

Andrew luck hardly has talent around him does he? Wayne was out most of the season so he had Hilton and fleener that's equates to smitty and olsen, still has better record than cam first two seasons. Not bashing cam but just saying luck has impressed me more than any other qb of late

Oh, the price I would pay to play in the AFC South. Then we could brag about our records too.

:(

[TheRed]

Welp, it's now an Andrew Luck thread. Great job huddle.

[ajax4132]

fify

First ballot one on top of that

[jptaylor84]

Lucks been impressive can't say he hasn't, hardly loaded with weapons is he bit like cam, but luck has a playoff win and puts up a ton of points, maybe cam needs lucks oc. Stil say an will be a better qb if and when he has weapons and a good Oline around him but we won't know until 2016

[AceBoogie]

Lol. Peyton Manning makes weapons out of WRs, not the other way around.

I think he is the best QB in history. Although Joe Montana I would not argue very hard against.

Brady has the rings, but I would still take Manning. I think rings are important but not the only criteria.

Those same guys that The Golden Calf of Bristol won a playoff game with?

[UNCrules2187]

The guy who just put up an NFL record 55 TDs is overrated?

 

whatisthisidon'teven

 

wat

 

[TheRed]

Lucks been impressive can't say he hasn't, hardly loaded with weapons is he bit like cam, but luck has a playoff win and puts up a ton of points, maybe cam needs lucks oc. Stil say an will be a better qb if and when he has weapons and a good Oline around him but we won't know until 2016

 

Indy brought in Luck's offensive coordinator who coached him at Stanford too.

 

When we drafted Cam we initially took proper steps to help him out, but we stopped and turned our attention to the defense. This offseason is the time. No more excuses. Build around him now. We don't have time to wait. I can only hope Shula is the right guy.

[jptaylor84]

Can't we bring in the guy who was at auburn with cam lol

[TheRed]

Can't we bring in the guy who was at auburn with cam lol

 

Point is they drafted him and immediately went all in with him. We barely went halfway.