Replace Cam with any other playoff QB - Do we win 12 games?

[bLACKpANTHER]

Do they win 12 games this year?

 

Tom Brady- Yeah, sure.. I believe he could work with the WRs and crappy O-line to dink and dunk his way to 12-4 record.

 

Peyton Manning- I don't believe he would make it through the season healthy behind our O-line. No.

 

Drew Brees- Maybe. The weapons he works with on the regular basis are far and above the crap Cam works with. Maybe.

 

Russel Wilson- Ultimate game manager- I say yes. He wouldn't have the run game like he does in Seattle, but I still say yes.

 

Crap-ernick- no, just fuggin no.

 

Andrew Luck- No, he doesn't protects the ball enough. Couple that with Lafell dropping passes or failing to create separation = fail.

 

Philip Rivers- Possibly. He is mobile enough and has enough "won't quit" in him to will the team to the playoffs, but not 12-4.

 

Aaron Rogers- Interesting, do we take into account the injury. If no and Rogers is healthy all year for the Panthers- I say yes.

 

Nick Foles- nope

 

Andy Dalton- nope

 

Alex Smith- nope

 

---------------------------

 

3 YES, 6 NO, 2 MAYBE

 

what say ye?

[SnowPanther]

Peyton Manning played behind some horrendous offensive lines in Indy with no run game to speak of and won 12 games consistently.........

[neverlosethefeeling]

What is your point, OP? Nobody can prove any of those scenarios right or wrong.

[ajax4132]

DangeRuss is a no, he has Marshawn Lynch and a top 10 o-line yet has shown to be nothing more than a game manager till this point.

No way in hell actually

[TheRed]

These hypothetical scenarios are irrelevant. We have who we have, and I am fine with it. Just keep putting talent around him.

[ajax4132]

To be honest the only qb that probably could would be Tom Brady

 

and maybe MAYBE Aaron Rodgers

 

Manning is a tad overrated, played with weapons his entire career

[Happy Panther]

Manning for sure

[TNPanther]

Replace the OP with any other OP. Does this thread still not make any sense?

[Mage]

Peyton Manning- I don't believe he would make it through the season healthy behind our O-line. No.

 

[bLACKpANTHER]

What is your point, OP? Nobody can prove any of those scenarios right or wrong.

 

welcome to the offseason

[Peppers90 NC]

 

 

3 YES, 6 NO, 2 MAYBE

 

what say ye?

i agree with the yes's, no to brees though but maybe Manning, he is just too good with what he does at the LOS, i think he would figure it out.  He and Brady are the only two QB's in the playoffs every year, and thats why i put them above everyone else, including Brees.

[natty]

Manning makes his O lines better.  He completely transforms offenses, so yes he'd do fine.  

[Happy Panther]

Manning is basically a coach out there. Probably has GM duties as well.

[Awesomeness!!]

Manning could win 12 games with him and 21 random dudes off of the huddle. Nobody else would win 10 games behind this line.