We're Better Without Stewart

[MichaelNewtonII]

without looking, 20 dollars says promethean forerunner is in this thread throwing a tantrum because somebody has called out his favorite player.

correct

Sent from my SGH-T399 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[CRA]

people fail to realize this is the same issue we had with gettis, all that potential but couldn't stay healthy.............unfortunately that's looking like stewarts case right now

No. Stewart is a proven and solid RB in the NFL when healthy.

Gettis made 3 catches that turned him into a folk legend

[Cpt slay a ho]

No. Stewart is a proven and solid RB in the NFL when healthy.

Gettis made 3 catches that turned him into a folk legend

 

gettis had a decent rookie year followed by being plagued with injuries.........then when it seem like he was back to form he got injured yet again.

 

 

Stewart in recent years has done near the same, good production on the field but somehow gets injured mid or late season, because of his cap he won't be cut but that's his case unless he comes back during play-off time.

 

it's the nfl things like this happen all the time not everyone is or will be as blessed as TD, i still have hope for stewart but it's looking thin

[CRA]

gettis had a decent rookie year followed by being plagued with injuries.........then when it seem like he was back to form he got injured yet again.

Stewart in recent years has done near the same, good production on the field but somehow gets injured mid or late season, because of his cap he won't be cut but that's his case unless he comes back during play-off time.

it's the nfl things like this happen all the time not everyone is or will be as blessed as TD, i still have hope for stewart but it's looking thin

Comparing Gettis to Stewart is an insult to Stewart.

[Cpt slay a ho]

Comparing Gettis to Stewart is an insult to Stewart.

 

well then your reading out of context. not comparing each as players but as guys who couldn't get pass injuries

[PantherFanOne]

It may have been the elephant in the room, but it’s never been a secret that the Panthers were eventually going to have to deal harshly with the contract situation at running back that Marty Hurney got this  franchise into. Heck, it was likely one of the interview questions Gettleman and the other job candidates had to field prior to getting the GM position..

Williams, with his inspired play this season while Stewart has been on the injury list, might just make Gettleman’s decision, and course of action, much easier.

[CRA]

well then your reading out of context. not comparing each as players but as guys who couldn't get pass injuries

Still an insult to Stewart...

and Gettis got healthy, and went to the dog house last year. He got healthy this year in camp and couldn't beat out tons of unimpressive guys.

[Montsta]

I like Stewart but he has like 500 total yards the last two years combined. Time to move on as soon as it's a realistic financial option.

[Cpt slay a ho]

Still an insult to Stewart...

and Gettis got healthy, and went to the dog house last year. He got healthy this year in camp and couldn't beat out tons of unimpressive guys.

 

due to injury gettis didn't beat out those guys, also florence got beat out as well.............not every decision made by the FO is a good one.

 

stewart can prove the doubters wrong if he comes back ready to ball for the play-offs, if not he is what he is a bob sanders type player

[Panthers8969]

People need to realize that double trouble is a thing of the past. Stewart is injured most of the time and when he does play our running game actually seems worse. This could be for lots of different reasons or it could just be in my head. Having cam Tolbert Williams and Stewart is just too much in the backfield anyways. I would prefer we let Stewart go and then draft a high round running back two years from now(assuming that's when dwill slows down)

[intangiblejohnny]

OK say what you wish pal. I have been a lifelong fan, i will try to find my picture of myself in my panthers beanie when i was 6 and wearing my peppers jersey and message it to you if possible. and its funny how old timers just use the eye ball test to judge a player still these days. there is a reason people like you are being replaced with people like myself, the people who study and pay attention to the NUMBERS. it all comes down to NUMBERS. numbers do not lie.

I'm sorry but that's just not true. Numbers lie constantly. Look at Cam's numbers since he has been in the league and tell me which of his three seasons have been more successful. Hmm...looks like we should have been happier with the two previous years than with with the current.

Football is not baseball and does not completely reflect results through statistics.

That doesn't really matter though as you seem to be more of a "madden" statistic sort of kid. For a real Panther fan you have no repsect you Stewart when you call him "trash" as, when he has been healthy during his tenure, he has ran incredibly hard for us racking up punishing yards against defenses.

That being said, I completely agree that D'Angeleo is the superior back, especially (and recently) exclusively, when he is featured.

[CRA]

due to injury gettis didn't beat out those guys, also florence got beat out as well.............not every decision made by the FO is a good one.

stewart can prove the doubters wrong if he comes back ready to ball for the play-offs, if not he is what he is a bob sanders type player

Claiming he is a Bob Sanders is a much better comparison IMO.

[MichaelNewtonII]

I'm sorry but that's just not true. Numbers lie constantly. Look at Cam's numbers since he has been in the league and tell me which of his three seasons have been more successful. Hmm...looks like we should have been happier with the two previous years than with with the current.

Football is not baseball and does not completely reflect results through statistics.

That doesn't really matter though as you seem to be more of a "madden" statistic sort of kid. For a real Panther fan you have no repsect you Stewart when you call him "trash" as, when he has been healthy during his tenure, he has ran incredibly hard for us racking up punishing yards against defenses.

That being said, I completely agree that D'Angeleo is the superior back, especially (and recently) exclusively, when he is featured.

 

touche

[megadeth078]

Laffell shouldn't be blocking 2 people downfield without holding.  The tackling was bad.