FYI: Would be "shocking" if Giants re-sign Nicks...

[*FreeFua*]

If he's better than what we got and comes cheap, how is that not a valid point?

Again, Nicks' down year is what LaFell does on average. Even a little better.

Just because he's better than what we got, doesn't make him good.

If we address the WR position in next years draft like we should, we won't be saying "he's better than what we got". I hope they don't sign him with that being the only reason, because after the draft (if drafting properly) he won't be better than what we got.

At 25 (or however old Nicks is) he already appears to be on the decline IMO. Just not a good idea to sign him.

[MCC]

Would love to have him at a fair price. He's definitely not worth top WR money, though.

 

I'd much rather draft a WR in the 1st/2nd and spend money on veteran FA O-lineman. 

[SZ James (banned)]

Take me to your dealer. Ginn is a nice piece to have, but let's be real here. He's the *#3 WR on one of the worst WR corps in the league.

 

*He is the most efficient receiver on the blahblahblah

[SZ James (banned)]

http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/wr

 

nvm looks like ss has improved

[SmootsDaddy89]

lol fun fact according to that Nicks is still better than anyone, ANYONE on our team.

[SZ James (banned)]

lol fun fact according to that Nicks is still better than anyone, ANYONE on our team.

yep. but this is how every thread goes:

a) that guy sucks

b) that guy is too expensive

c) both a and b

 

every. fuging. one.

[CamWow]

Nicks is overrated

[CamWow]

lol fun fact according to that Nicks is still better than anyone, ANYONE on our team.

You mean receiver? And what about smitty?

[PhillyB]

Zero TD's. Zero.

As in not even one.

Whatever your argument is, I reply "Zero."

 

DD stole my response. you can't necessarily judge a receiver by a single bad season still in progress (not all the time anyway.) he's on pace for 971 yards this season... a big play more and he's over a thousand.

 

i'm not sold either but let's not pretend he's just shitting the bed completely

[TheRed]

Why is it we have a thread about this motherfuger what seems like once every month?

I really thought we wouldn't have to see anymore after the trade deadline passed. Give it a damn rest.

[rodeo]

I wouldn't count Nicks as the solution to our offense, but I most certainly wouldn't mind adding him as a piece of it.

[L-TownCat]

Nicks is the type of receiver we should be targeting. I'm not saying nicks is the guy but a big guy with big hands is a "Cam" receiver. We really need to use the draft for oline. Gotta get help there first.

[PantherFanOne]

Something to keep an eye on...

http://espn.go.com/blog/new-york/giants/post/_/id/33027/twitter-mailbag-gilbride-thoughts

Giants have to give a new contract to Eli. They also have to sign Tuck. Nicks is coming off a down year. There's a real good chance he could come here with a not so big contract. Hope it works out.

 

Nicks' best chance of getting a free-agent deal from the Giants is if the team chalks this year up to a larger mess and decides it's worth taking a long-term chance on him at a relatively reasonable cost.

But even in that case, Nicks would have to be willing to sign for reasonable money. If he's after top-dollar, and there's a team like the Panthers willing to pay for his talent and pre-2013 track record, he's likely going elsewhere.

[MichaelNewtonII]

COME ON DOWN TO CURRRLINA

Sent from my SGH-T399 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app