Mike Tolbert has been the Panthers best running back this year.

[CRA]

What is this too sensitive about Williams crap. I am talking about you saying the run game will get better when Stewart got back out on the field. I am talking about you saying Barner should start over Williams because he can make something out of nothing better than Williams. You can call it what you want. You remember what you want to remember. You talk out of both sides of your mouth all the time. This "Stewart runs better without blocking" nonsense is just bull. Get out of here with that. If DeAngelo would have fumbled against San Fran you would have been all on this forum saying he is fumble prone. DeAngelo has made plays this year for this team. When you get through running your mouth about Stewart being better behind a poor line, he hasnt made plays since he has been back. Which is what he was supposed to do according to you. Because he creates his own holes and DeAngelo cant.

Stewart running better with no hole isn't bull.....it is backed up by fact this year, which is why he is notably better and gains more yardage after contact.

Due to our crappy OL....RBs get contact almost immediately.

I don't get caught up in "starter" bull poo. We have a committee. It means certain weeks certain RBs should see the bench more than others.

Williams is overall a middle of the road RB at this point in his career. Can he make plays and has he? Yes.....but your posting is an example of people being overly sensitive about Williams. He isn't the answer and no one bashing him. We need an OL. Until we get an OL....Tolbert and Stewart make the most sense getting the bulk of the snaps in a POWER and up the gut run scheme.

And Barner will suck running him up the gut with no holes... Today didn't show anything in regards to anything. He wasn't suppose to show anything with those carries other than he can take a beating. Like Williams he needs space to operate...and Rbs like that need blocking or play calls to obtain it.

[beastlypanda]

I noticed most of Stews runs came with a wall of players in front of him. O line isnt making any holes so its kinda of expected. I also noticed there were quite a few nice lanes for tolbert to run through not sure if tolbert was lucky by having the lanes develop due to Oline or defensive formation or if its skill. 

[CRA]

It's true CRA you are one of maybe 3 posters who I don't trust to discuss our RBs rationally. No offense intended at all.

no offense taken. Most posters bring bias to topics...I have mine.

I don't think I overrate players like many. I may devalue some....but someone has to help bring this into the middle where things probably really belong

[Awesomeness!!]

Most expensive 41 yards ever.

[Yaboychris28]

Statsically, I would wager Williams goes down for no gain or 1 yard more often than Stewart

28 is better after contact....Williams' rare nice runs aid his ypc

You can argue with me all you want. Williams is the better back plain and simple

[B.BERSIN]

but our oline sucks on blocking for backs. It seems when Mike is on the field, the oline plays a little better, so Stew just dont have any chance on running between tackles.

 

that said, Mike is a better on in this game, I will bench Stew in my fantasy next week

[csx]

The short bus

[CRA]

You can argue with me all you want. Williams is the better back plain and simple

You can argue with me all you want. Williams is the better back plain and simple

Meh, neither is anything to write home about behind this OL.

Tolbert is the best overall.

[pstall]

Tolbert looks hungier. On a couple of levels.

Sent from my SPH-L710 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[intangiblejohnny]

I have strong opinions about our backfield but I just can't bring myself to complain while we are playing so well. I hope the o line and our backs begin to produce like the rest of our game so we don't have to have this conversation in the future.

[tjmurray]

Stewart running better with no hole isn't bull.....it is backed up by fact this year, which is why he is notably better and gains more yardage after contact.

Due to our crappy OL....RBs get contact almost immediately.

I don't get caught up in "starter" bull poo. We have a committee. It means certain weeks certain RBs should see the bench more than others.

Williams is overall a middle of the road RB at this point in his career. Can he make plays and has he? Yes.....but your posting is an example of people being overly sensitive about Williams. He isn't the answer and no one bashing him. We need an OL. Until we get an OL....Tolbert and Stewart make the most sense getting the bulk of the snaps in a POWER and up the gut run scheme.

And Barner will suck running him up the gut with no holes... Today didn't show anything in regards to anything. He wasn't suppose to show anything with those carries other than he can take a beating. Like Williams he needs space to operate...and Rbs like that need blocking or play calls to obtain it.

Whatever CRA.... My posting was asking you about your claim that Stewart would improve our running game. That he would be an upgrade once he got out on the field. The only FACT is that he hasn't improved the running game as YOU claimed he would. All that other poo you posted had nothing to do with what I asked you. You get caught up with who is starting more than anyone on this board. You are hilarious.If DeAngelo is middle of the road, what in the hell has Stewart been the last 2 years? Have a seat..

[MichaelNewtonII]

Stewart looks absolutely terrible. I really don't know what people expected, he's had one great season his entire career.

people on the huddle were crucifying me for saying stew wouldnt be the same and to trade him. But once again im looking correct.

Sent from my SGH-T399 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[Cpt slay a ho]

Some of you guys really confuse me......you'll admit our o line sucks(besides gross and ryan) but then state that our rbs suck, no they don't suck and neither rb is significantly better then the other.....each of our rbs excel in certain situations

[CRA]

Whatever CRA.... My posting was asking you about your claim that Stewart would improve our running game. That he would be an upgrade once he got out on the field. The only FACT is that he hasn't improved the running game as YOU claimed he would. All that other poo you posted had nothing to do with what I asked you. You get caught up with who is starting more than anyone on this board. You are hilarious.If DeAngelo is middle of the road, what in the hell has Stewart been the last 2 years? Have a seat..

Williams is middle of the road

So is Stewart

They are different. Give me he middle of the road RB who deals with contact best. If we had an OL that creates big holes give me Williams.