Ed Reed released....should Panthers sign?

[chknwing]

we have good character players in our locker room.  we do not need a guy that talks poo about his own team to the media.  Voice your frustrations in the lockeroom, not to the media.

[KaseKlosed]

give him a clipboard and have him coach up up the sideline. instant 2 INTS per game 

[CLTPanther]

For what? Our cheerleading squad is full and he was near dead last in safety stats

[AceMan]

Should have retired with Ray Ray

[Trenches]

He will be a New England Patriot.  Can still play and did not decline mentally.

[PantherFanOne]

No way do I want Reed. He was a great one but his best days are behind him.

[dos poptarts]

Could the Panthers use a HOF Safety to compliment our young secondary and make Superbowl run.......or dont mess with current Defense chemistry?

 

No. Hell no. The answer is absolutely fuggin NO!

 

I live in Houston and made fun of my co-workers that Reed was a desparation signing. He isn't good anymore, he probably isn't healthy, and the Texans haven't won a game since he started playing.

 

I'm taking the Texans to win on Sunday.

[Jmac]

Crazy talk.......sign everyone

[carolina-chuck]

Can he play WR?

[bababoey]

Can he play G?

This. 

[rodeo]

He got benched weeks ago before he was cut. He sucks.

[Mr. Scot]

This is the kind of thing I've talked about before, i.e. the mistake of valuing someone based on who they used to be rather than who they are now.

Would I want the Ed Reed of five years ago? Sure. Problem is that guy doesn't exist anymore. And the Ed Reed of right now is so broken down I wouldn't even want him as a backup.

Nostalgia makes for bad football.

[KendrickPanther]

Most predictable thread of the year. We get these threads when guys like Ochocinco are released.

[KendrickPanther]

I got one name for you, Reggie White. Loved him as a packer. Sad as a Panther.