Jonathon Martin

[Proudiddy]

Could be, but he went to the GM before he left to complain specifically about Incognito. He didn't make it up after the fact.

Welp, forget all of that conjecture I just typed on then, lol.

I didn't know anything regarding Incognito took place before Martin left. Nevermind then... Then my original stance is reinvoked - the Dolphins front office and coaching staff is horrible and should be out of jobs.

[Cary Kollins]

Welp, forget all of that conjecture I just typed on then, lol.

I didn't know anything regarding Incognito took place before Martin left. Nevermind then... Then my original stance is reinvoked - the Dolphins front office and coaching staff is horrible and should be out of jobs.

 

 

Dolphin's GM Jeff Ireland told Martin's agent that Martin should stand up to Incognito and "punch him".

[csx]

Did you read the transcript?  What part of "I'm going to make you eat poo" or "half-n*gger" or "i'm going to slap your real mother" do you not get?

 

 

Why would Martin walk away from a NFL contract and check into a hospital?  Just to get the public behind a cause?

 

 

Doesn't add up to me.

 

It sounds terrible but it's not like I haven't heard people say much worse things and not mean a thing by it. 

[Proudiddy]

Did you read the transcript? What part of "I'm going to make you eat poo" or "half-n*gger" or "i'm going to slap your real mother" do you not get?

Why would Martin walk away from a NFL contract and check into a hospital? Just to get the public behind a cause?

Doesn't add up to me.

No, I was saying if the Incognito stuff was made up after the fact, then checking into the hospital could strengthen Martin's case.

Don't get me wrong, I wasn't victim blaming, I was just saying "what if?"

I've been behind Martin from the beginning, from what we know on the outside... I was just saying what if we've all been played?

But, then Happy Panther just mentioned Martin going to the GM before he ever left, so that pretty much sunk that battleship, lol.

So, now I go back to the otherside of the argument and think about how awkward and inept that Ireland AND Philbin looked on Hard Knocks last year. I really think they shouldn't have been in the positions they are in.

[Cary Kollins]

No, I was saying if the Incognito stuff was made up after the fact, then checking into the hospital could strengthen Martin's case.

Don't get me wrong, I wasn't victim blaming, I was just saying "what if?"

I've been behind Martin from the beginning, from what we know on the outside... I was just saying what if we've all been played?

But, then Happy Panther just mentioned Martin going to the GM before he ever left, so that pretty much sunk that battleship, lol.

So, now I go back to the otherside of the argument and think about hiw awkward and inept that Ireland AND Philbin looked on Hard Knocks last year. I really think they shouldn't have been in the positions they are in.

Yeah it's going to be bad for them I think. Like real bad. Like bounty-scandal type bad when Goodell gets finished with this.

[Proudiddy]

Yeah it's going to be bad for them I think. Like real bad. Like bounty-scandal type bad when Goodell gets finished with this.

Yeah, with what you guys just told me about Ireland before Martin left, now it appears they orchestrated the whole thing from the top by telling Incognito to toughen him up. Then, when Martin couldn't take it anymore, Ireland wants him to prove his toughness by "punching" another one of his players, lol. Then Martin leaves and Ireland and Philbin basically lie, say they knew nothing about it, and then apparently have instructed the team to follow suit and cover it up.

All I keep thinking about is how "soft" Philbin looked when he had to release Chad Johnson... these guys fooled a lot of people into giving them these jobs.

[Happy Panther]

My latest theory:

 

Incognito and Martin were gay lovers. Incognito was harsh on him at times to keep up a facade. But then they had a spat and the voicemail became a way for Martin to get back at Richie.

[Proudiddy]

Lol, I hadn't thought about that, but I did think there were some very supressed homoerotic feeling bubbling underneath Incognito's voicemail... "I'll poo in your mouth?" Who says that?

[Cary Kollins]

Yeah, with what you guys just told me about Ireland before Martin left, now it appears they orchestrated the whole thing from the top by telling Incognito to toughen him up. Then, when Martin couldn't take it anymore, Ireland wants him to prove his toughness by "punching" another one of his players, lol. Then Martin leaves and Ireland and Philbin basically lie, say they knew nothing about it, and then apparently have instructed the team to follow suit and cover it up.

All I keep thinking about is how "soft" Philbin looked when he had to release Chad Johnson... these guys fooled a lot of people into giving them these jobs.

 

 

 

Also I've read multiple places that Incognito is really a dumb guy.  So the Dolphins FO tells Incognito to "toughen up" Martin and Incognito being the big dummy he is takes it too far.

 

Not good for anyone involved.

[Mr. Scot]

So, we go from labeling Martin in the beginning, to labeling Incognito, to now, not knowing what the heck to think.

Glad I did not go all in early on with this one.

I'm still not completely sure what to make of Martin, but I have never had any reason to waver about incognito.

I already knew he was a colossal douchebag long before this story came out. Nothing of what he's being accused of surprises me.

[KillerKat]

Who gives a poo if Martin is introverted? Who gives a poo if Martin and Incognito used to hang out? Bottom line is Incognito is a piece of poo for what he said and he deserves to be chastised for it. And any player siding with Incognito or blaming the victim Martin here can go to hell.

[Razeyfingers]

My latest theory:

 

Incognito and Martin were gay lovers. Incognito was harsh on him at times to keep up a facade. But then they had a spat and the voicemail became a way for Martin to get back at Richie.

 

Was that you who called into Rome today?

 

Hilarious, that was exactly what was speculated by a caller at one point. . Im assuming the dude was joking but he didnt sound like it.

[Happy Panther]

Was that you who called into Rome today?

 

Hilarious, that was exactly what was speculated by a caller at one point. . Im assuming the dude was joking but he didnt sound like it.

 

lol no wasn't me!

[Razeyfingers]

lol no wasn't me!

 

Yeah it was kind of funny, Rome cut him off short naturally before giving a slight dig.