Stewart for Nicks?

[MichaelNewtonII]

There is speculation of a possible trade between the Giants and Panthers: Jonathon Stewart for Hakeem Nicks. I for one think it would help both teams and with the resurgent DeAngelo Williams and the promising Kenjon Barner, think it would be in our best interest to fill a need at Wide Receiver while getting rid of a Running Back that isn't really needed due to the success of the running game without him. Would you do this trade, why or why not?

[Jaxel]

There is a 7 page thread already about this same topic..

[Vampire the buffet slayer]

Smh.

[davos]

oh lawdy

[Vampire the buffet slayer]

I thought maybe some new info or something.

[mbarbour21]

Yes

Both injury prone

Good with dwill & tolbert

But it really depends on what gettleman and rivera think about dwills future with the team. And of course, CONTRACTS.

[davos]

this thread is now about....

 

[Coug Girl]

I thought maybe some new info or something.

Same here.

Honestly the Giants just signed Peyton Hillis to a 1 yr. and I think have Brown coming back. Would I do the trade, yes (of course if it doesn't fug us too much in cap).

[Swaggasaurus]

What it weird is that you started this thread 18 minutes after posting in the same existing thread....why???

[Happy Panther]

There is speculation of a possible trade between the Giants and Panthers: Jonathon Stewart for Hakeem Nicks. I for one think it would help both teams and with the resurgent DeAngelo Williams and the promising Kenjon Barner, think it would be in our best interest to fill a need at Wide Receiver while getting rid of a Running Back that isn't really needed due to the success of the running game without him. Would you do this trade, why or why not?

 

What would you do with Nicks? He is going to be making $15m/yr starting next year. We will struggle to create the cap space.

 

Bringing him in for a playoff run this year would make sense but Cam is working well with Ginn and Lafell so far.

[Argus Plexus]

RBs are not equal in value to WRs