Nicks

[Strawman]

Have been paying close attention to him vs Bears, seems more like a great #2, rather than a #1 TBH. Combine that with the previous injury issues, and I'm not sure the expectations / hopes I've seen here about signing him next year as Steve's replacement are realistic.

BTW Randle is a worse version of LaFell.

Anyone remember what the Bears gave the Dolphins for Marshall? He's a beast.

[SuperJTheGreat]

Trade Hardy. Pickup Pep.

[CelibatePimp]

True, Nicks is what a true number 2 should be. When I think number 1, I am talking about a beast like Julio Jones or Jimmy Graham (I know he's not a WR but he has WR numbers).

[Anybodyhome]

I thought Victor Cruz was the #1 and Nicks was the #2?

 

And Randle is getting 3 catches/50 yards a game is as good as you'll see for a #3.

[jayflip]

I don't like how Nicks has been holding the ball after the catch.

[SgtJoo]

I don't like how Nicks has been holding the ball after the catch.

 

With one hand?

 

lawl

[*FreeFua*]

Have been paying close attention to him vs Bears, seems more like a great #2, rather than a #1 TBH. Combine that with the previous injury issues, and I'm not sure the expectations / hopes I've seen here about signing him next year as Steve's replacement are realistic.

BTW Randle is a worse version of LaFell.

Anyone remember what the Bears gave the Dolphins for Marshall? He's a beast.

Agreed, I don't want them to break the bank for Nicks or even come remotely close to doing anything like that for him.

Marshall was traded for a 2012 third round pick and 2013 third round pick. I was pissed the Panthers passed on a legit number 1 wide reciever when the asking price was more than reasonable.

I want them to trade for Josh Gordon so bad.

[Guest Spider Monkey]

Nicks would take a fair offer to play in Charlotte. He loves Charlotte, the Panthers, and the idea of playing with Cam/Steve. Unfortunately, I doubt we offer him anything.

[Fox007]

I thought Victor Cruz was the #1 and Nicks was the #2?

 

And Randle is getting 3 catches/50 yards a game is as good as you'll see for a #3.

 

Nicks is #1 Cruz #2

 

Cruz plays in the slot a bunch as well.

[Anybodyhome]

Nicks is #1 Cruz #2

 

Cruz plays in the slot a bunch as well.

 

Meh, Cruz is the better receiver, in my opinion, but he's getting all the doubles now.

[CPF4LIFE]

The ideal number 1  for this offense has to be a deep threat which Nicks doesnt fit, but he would be a hell of a number 2 as a possession guy. Still worth it, and Randle is a better receiver than Lafell in every way. U gotta be kidding me with that remark.

[Fox007]

Meh, Cruz is the better receiver, in my opinion, but he's getting all the doubles now.

 

Well your  best WR doesn't necessarily have to be your "#1"

 

Welker would never be considered a #1 but has been the best WR on a couple teams.

[nickzz]

nicks has it all. only knock on him is his history of being injury prone.

[PntherPryd]

Nicks obviously has the tools but not loving some of the intangibles in regards to catching the ball away from his body and running the route the qb obviously expects him to run.  Communication is lacking with Eli and not real happy with effort level on a couple of plays either.

 

Playing with Steve and Cam may fix that, but still a big question mark.