Geno Smith > Cam Newton

[Squirrel]

We will find out Dec 15th.

[MichaelNewtonII]

compare td's though... im sure cam had more than 5tds in 5 weeks

Its 11.

 

 

Cam his rookie year after 5 games had 6 ints and 1 fumble

Geno after 5 games had 8 ints and 3 fumbles.

 

 

If geno has a clean game next week.  Cam rookie years will pass him.

 

[Mr. Scot]

We have arguably the worst head coach in the league and arguably the worst offensive coordinator in the league.

Until we bring in a legitimate head coach and OC there will be a culture of losing.

Ahem...

http://cincinnati.com/blogs/bengals/2013/10/07/the-walkthrough-absurd-stats-edition/

:D

[MichaelNewtonII]

compare 5 games touchdowns though, i just checked. Cam had 12 tds compared to 8 by Geno through 5 games

Its 11.

 

 

Cam his rookie year after 5 games had 6 ints and 1 fumble

Geno after 5 games had 8 ints and 3 fumbles.

 

 

If geno has a clean game next week.  Cam rookie years will pass him.

 

[Squirrel]

compare 5 games touchdowns though, i just checked. Cam had 12 tds compared to 8 by Geno through 5 games

 

 

Fact is Geno doesn't run the ball in for TD near the goal line.  The Jets let their running backs do that.  Something the Panthers didn't do when Cam was a rookie.   On passing TD's they are the same.  Plus Jets are 3-2 and Panthers was 1-4 at the time.

[mbarbour21]

Rookie is 3-2 while beating Falcons in their house

3 yr QB is 1-3

Most people will say QB's are good based on wins. Smith is on an upward trajectory and we are not.

Thats how these threads are born

Okay so that makes Geno better than Cam, Eli, RGIII, Matt Ryan, Bradford, and more.

[Jangler]

Well then we don't need 20+ people that refer to themselves as "mods" if we are going to just let this place run into the ground.

 

we don't need no stinking mods.

 

 

We...the people have pretty much been able to control and run the sh!tters out of here, can't see that changing anytime soon.

 

 

 

anyways...I like reading stupid threads and posts, I make them all the time.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

Okay so that makes Geno better than Cam, Eli, RGIII, Matt Ryan, Bradford, and more.

 

there's some convoluted reason why the iron-clad air tight argument presented in the OP and espoused by several others in this thread doesn't apply to them i'm sure

[Luck0wnsCam]

Andrew Luck > (S)Cam Newton

 

the only thing Scam does better than Luck is lose games.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

Andrew Luck > (S)Cam Newton

 

the only thing Scam does better than Luck is lose games.

 

everybody get mad and reply to this person he'll never see it coming

[Jangler]

Doesn't Carolina and Indy have to play...and Luck to win for Luck to own Cam???

 

 

gtfo until they play.

 

 

everybody get mad and reply to this person he'll never see it coming

 

 

done and done

[BigBoss]

What does Geno have that Cam never has had? A winning record.

[Luck0wnsCam]

Andrew Luck 15-6

 

Cam Newton 14-22

 

Both took over the worst team in the NFL, one is now a good team the other team still sucks, the rest is just excuses from deluded Panther fans who refuse to accept Cam was just another one year wonder option QB.

[Jangler]

Thanks for the update.