The Cam Newton thread to end all threads.

[Former Bill On Vacation]

J Kelly NFL HOF 1st year eligible. 4 superbowls.

[MHS831]

  The Cam hate is actually Panther hate!

 

No it isn't.

 

That is the problem.  You can't discuss his shortcomings without Cam Nuthuggers calling you a hater.  I can love the panthers and criticize Cam.

 

Sorry that this can't be put in a box for you and others to make it simple, but sometimes, there are other emotions that motivate criticism. 

 

I say this:  If you think Cam is great and anyone who suggests that he is flawed is a Panther hater, then you like going 7-9--his best season.

 

(This is where you blame everyone around him and ignore his questionable mechanics, leadership, accuracy, and ability to read a defense).

[CPF4LIFE]

LOL at Bills fans trolling a week after the game.

[TheRumGone]

J Kelly NFL HOF 1st year eligible. 4 superbowls.

 

we realize that bill but you brought up intelligence.

 

kelly scored a 15. cam scored a 21.

[tiger7_88]

we realize that bill but you brought up intelligence.

 

kelly scored a 15. cam scored a 21.

 

 

Bill-On-Vacation: "BUT JIM KELLY WAS IN FOUR SUPERBOWLS!"

[TheRed]

No it isn't.

That is the problem. You can't discuss his shortcomings without Cam Nuthuggers calling you a hater. I can love the panthers and criticize Cam.

Sorry that this can't be put in a box for you and others to make it simple, but sometimes, there are other emotions that motivate criticism.

I say this: If you think Cam is great and anyone who suggests that he is flawed is a Panther hater, then you like going 7-9--his best season.

(This is where you blame everyone around him and ignore his questionable mechanics, leadership, accuracy, and ability to read a defense).

Well, we've officially gotten our first nut huggers reference. This thread is now complete.

Everyone should just sit down, be quiet, and listen to MHS, because apparently only he can be right about anything.

[rodeo]

Cam's career has been very similar to Kelly's through his first two years. Same TDs, more yards, better completion %, better record.

 

Oh yeah, except Cam also has a bunch of rushing TDs.

 

Cam Newton > Jim Kelly at the same point in their careers.

[rodeo]

I wonder if BIlls fans were making forum posts in 1988 saying it's time to move on because he had such accuracy issues and a terrible record in his first 2 years.

 

 

[TheRed]

I keep hearing about 4 superbowls, but what he always leaves out is that the Bills lost them all.

[TheRumGone]

or questioning his intelligence with that awesome 15 on the wonderlic

[Who Said What?]

(This is where you blame everyone around him and ignore his questionable mechanics, leadership, accuracy, and ability to read a defense).

 

The thing that crushes your pathetic argument is his questionable mechanics, leadership, accuracy, and this new bullshit about Cam's being unable to read a defense has got us into position to win all of the games in his career except two.  Those were the Giants game and the Titans game.  Find a player who consistently puts us in a position to lose like Captain Munnerlyn or Byron Bell.  Start a few threads on that.

 

[AceBoogie]

The thing that crushes your pathetic argument is his questionable mechanics, leadership, accuracy, and this new bullshit about Cam's being unable to read a defense has got us into position to win all of the games in his career except two. Those were the Giants game and the Titans game. Find a player who consistently puts us in a position to lose like Captain Munnerlyn or Byron Bell. Start a few threads on that.

Cam has his things he need to work on I just hate when people say he can't read a defense and he's just a big guy with a strong arm. That's crazy. If that was the case defenses should have kept him from breaking records.

[†William Moore†]

LOL

[cbully]

No it isn't.

 

That is the problem.  You can't discuss his shortcomings without Cam Nuthuggers calling you a hater.  I can love the panthers and criticize Cam.

 

Sorry that this can't be put in a box for you and others to make it simple, but sometimes, there are other emotions that motivate criticism. 

 

I say this:  If you think Cam is great and anyone who suggests that he is flawed is a Panther hater, then you like going 7-9--his best season.

 

(This is where you blame everyone around him and ignore his questionable mechanics, leadership, accuracy, and ability to read a defense).

meh... we have had many dropped balls, questionable routes, far too many O-line collapses, lack of run ability to really blame the QB. All those flaws are the things that make him one dimensional. actually any QB. Therefore the coaching and apparently the budget is forcing us to deal with what we have. On a side not, if I'm RR and likely on way out, why would I fix all these problems at this point? The issues are bigger than Cam Newton himself. I'm not at all saying he is flawless but its not like he's fumbling at the 7 yard line when on course to win the game, dropping pass, lightly breaded covering WRS and making them look good, running out of bounds on ST, collecting unsportsman like conduct penalties that destroy momentum, and sure not calling ridiculous plays on 3rd and short. Not to mention conservative game play which contradicts the aggressive nature that put us in position to close the game. So at the end of the day, yes those around him have done far more to take the blame of why we are sucking thus far right now.