Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

PFF posts its ratings for all teams

SauceBoss

By SauceBoss,
in Carolina Panthers

Recommended Posts

JawnyBlaze Grand Master

JawnyBlaze

Posted
Posted

PFF's ratings are based on stats. How can you expect them to give a high grade to someone who's been injured last year? They're not gonna invent some training camp, recovering-from-injury metric just for something like this. I trust these guys -- their evaluations are certainly more justified than the regular fan's.

 

If it was just based on stats they wouldn't have graded Cam and Tannehill the same.

 

I do like PFF and usually value their stat systems.  This time, however, I think there is less value in what they're saying.  And I'm not even just complaining about what they said about some Panthers.  Like someone pointed out above, if Jimmy Graham isn't an elite TE who the hell is?!  A fully healthy Gronk is the only TE that's better than Graham today.  Which means Graham is the best and will probably be the best for a while to come.  And rating Dwan Edwards the same as Nakamura is a joke.  Dwan was bad in run defense, but good in pass defense.  In every aspect of the game, Nakamura was worse than Dwan's worst aspect. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Montsta Community Regular

Montsta

Posted
Posted

PFF's ratings are based on stats. How can you expect them to give a high grade to someone who's been injured last year? They're not gonna invent some training camp, recovering-from-injury metric just for something like this. I trust these guys -- their evaluations are certainly more justified than the regular fan's.

If it grades out on stats, then how was Luck given the second highest color rating when he had one of the worst passer ratings in football last year?

It's all hype man. No matter what site you are reading and feel like they know more than the other guys, it's all hype. Cam had a comparable year to his rookie year from an efficiency standpoint, but his hype died because of all the losses. Meanwhile, Bob Knee, Luck, and Kaepernick all received the media hype, and so have graded out higher. Even Kuechly is ridiculous. He is the best 4-3 MLB in football and if he played for a hyped team like Dallas he'd of gotten a blue elite rating.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Thorrez Collaborator

Thorrez

Posted
Posted

Guys, here is the deal in short:

 

This is NOT based stats or opinions.

 

This is what they do:

1. Check every play on the coaches view cameras. 

2. Check every "battle" on that play, can be anything like a guard trying to block a dt, a wr trying to do a catch or a lb trying to cover the flat.

3. If you clearly win your battle, you grade some positive number on the play, if you lose you grade minus and of course no score change if you draw.

 

* So a player like Luke (last year) did not grade elite even though his run blocking abilities graded that way because he graded negatively in pass protection. 

 

* The system will also over value player that do a very high number of easy assignments (like the short passes RGIII or Alex Smith are asked to do).

 

* Also note that they try to isolate one player, so a qb will grade positively on a incompletion on a perfect pass if the receiver should have caught it but dropped it.

 

Even though it is not perfect, it is by far the based grading system out there (available to us fans anyway).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...