Who's the better receiver?

[Ken]

How can this not be LaFell? Have not seen enough of Gettis to say he's better than LaFell......

[rayzor]

Thats true, but then again when Gettis caught that pass he was gone to the endzone. Lafell needed a block from Smitty to make that play as big as it was once he caught it so it kinda brings it down a couple notches.

 

gettis missing two years knocks him down a few more notches.

 

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

I would think that the answer would be obvious. Neither is all-pro and only one played last year. I'll go with the one that actually played.

 

 

[TheRumGone]

Not in the chiefs game.

 

I don't think that had anything to do with his hands. He just took his eyes off the ball.

[Vampire the buffet slayer]

"TheRed" and I would like to know from the huddler's opinion, who is better: Brandon LaFail or David Gettis (assuming both are healthy).

Wow.

Can I buy some pot from you?

[CPF4LIFE]

I don't think that had anything to do with his hands. He just took his eyes off the ball.

 

I think it does, eye coordination and hands kinda go together. You cant catch pass your not lookin at or concentrating on.

[TheRumGone]

I think it does, eye coordination and hands kinda go together. You cant catch pass your not lookin at or concentrating on.

 

Yea i get that. I just meant when people think of "stone hands" it's just because they have butterfinger hands. I know what you mean though.

[Jaxel]

I think LaFell is on his way. He would have had over 800, but he missed a couple of games due to injury, and to be honest, Cam wasn't playing that well at the beginning of the year.

[top dawg]

Did you really think that Gettis could possibly win this?  He doesn't have enough of a sample size to even be in this poll really.  It's like comparing an apple to a lemon. Better comparisons would be between LaFell and Hixon or Ginn, but even that wouldn't provide the best of polls.  Let's give it another year (or at least a camp and preseason) on the field as Panthers before we begin attributing value to our guys.

[Dex]

The ceiling is higher for Gettis but he just hasn't put the time in.

[TheRed]

I see the Gettis homers are still clinging to the Ravens game three years ago. Let's live in the past!

[CarolinaCoolin]

This thread is stupid. The answer is obvious

[Future of the Funchise]

stupid thread is stupid... i didn't even make it past the first page.

[Ivan The Awesome]

Well Chuck also thinks Armanti Edwards should make the roster because he had 1 TD in 3 years.

Um did I miss something. When did Armanti... Score a TD?