Who's the better receiver?

[TheRed]

you know a better question would have been who is better between gettis, pilares, and AE because those are the three guys he's going to be fighting for even just a roster spot....meanwhile lafell is sitting quite comfortably at the #2 spot while hixon and ginn will be fighting for the #3 spot.

while i wish we had a better #2 than lafell, he's got that job sown up. gettis doesn't even have a roster spot sewed up. that, in itself, should tell you who is better. if gettis was better, there'd be no question about his status on the team or his having a roster spot.

Don't forget Joe Adams is in the mix fighting for a spot too.

[carolina-chuck]

you know a better question would have been who is better between gettis, pilares, and AE because those are the three guys he's going to be fighting for even just a roster spot....meanwhile lafell is sitting quite comfortably at the #2 spot while hixon and ginn will be fighting for the #3 spot.

 

while i wish we had a better #2 than lafell, he's got that job sown up. gettis doesn't even have a roster spot sewed up. that, in itself, should tell you who is better. if gettis was better, there'd be no question about his status on the team or his having a roster spot.

 

Yea, but Gettis' inability to play is his injury.

AE and Pilares inabilities to play are their lack of performance.

[carolina-chuck]

Why's that???

 

quoting previous post:

 

"IMO, Both are liabilities. Both do not even deserve to be on a NFL team right now over some other guys that are still searching for jobs.

 

It doesnt matter who gets a spot or not.

 

Considering that Pilares is coming off an injury and adding Ginn and Barner, what are we going to do with Pilares? AE sucks so bad but at times, we could throw his ass for some trick plays/wildcat/etc to keep Defense guessing. I never said ones better than another. IMO, i just think that AE has the edge over Pilares."

[TheRumGone]

You did. omfg

You basically said the man was fat. He weighed 330lbs and was tired.

kidding me? and really? Having a vendetta on me after that argument? let it go already man. let it go

 

I'm one of the biggest Star supporters you will find here. the end.

[La Pantera]

That was before Olsen and Olsen and Shockey in 2011. Lafell is the 3rd option.

What was LaFells rookie #'s with the same QB play?

[rayzor]

Don't forget Joe Adams is in the mix fighting for a spot too.

 

true, but i think he's got one pretty much sewn up as well.

 

i see a corps of smith, lafell, hixon, ginn, adams, and one of gettis, AE, or pilares.

 

[Gallagher]

Gettis will never be healthy, trick question.

 

 

Lafell is the best receiver we've developed since....?

 

Just looked back through our draft history, and sadly enough Keary Colbert or maybe Drew Carter. It's been a while.

[carolina-chuck]

I'm one of the biggest Star supporters you will find here. the end.

 

Yes, you're one of the only "few" that support Star.

[La Pantera]

quoting previous post:

"IMO, Both are liabilities. Both do not even deserve to be on a NFL team right now over some other guys that are still searching for jobs.

It doesnt matter who gets a spot or not.

Considering that Pilares is coming off an injury and adding Ginn and Barner, what are we going to do with Pilares? AE sucks so bad but at times, we could throw his ass for some trick plays/wildcat/etc to keep Defense guessing. I never said ones better than another. IMO, i just think that AE has the edge over Pilares."

With the return game locked down, the last WR spots will go to the best recievers… in that reguard. Pilares is a better WR than AE.

[TheRed]

Both are liabilities. Both do not even deserve to be on a NFL team right now over some other guys that are still searching for jobs.

It doesnt matter who gets a spot or not. Why do you care so much. You act like we're going to find the next Cruz or Johnny Knox with Pilares.

Considering that Pilares is coming off an injury and adding Ginn and Barner, what are we going to do with Pilares? AE sucks so bad but at times, we could throw his ass for some trick plays/wildcat/etc to keep Defense guessing. I never said ones better than another. IMO, i just think that AE has the edge over Pilares.

But its the huddle. One cant have an "opinion".

If Hurney could have drafted a WR worth a damn we wouldn't be arguing about the 4th or 5th spot.

[carolina-chuck]

What was LaFells rookie #'s with the same QB play?

 

Similar,

38 rec, 468 yds, 1 td

 

But we've seen Gettis take over a game, have yet to see Lafell manage to be a game changer.

[carolina-chuck]

If Hurney could have drafted a WR worth a damn we wouldn't be arguing about the 4th or 5th spot.

 

Why did we all cheered for the Armanti pick back then?

[AceBoogie]

he was the no.2 last year

No 2 WR yes but he's the 3rd option behind Smitty and Olsen.

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Gettis basically had 2 good games. Lafell has shown that he is a legitimate starter that can stay healthy. Gettis had some great promise, but until he gets back on the field again and does something, it is definitely Lafell.