Star/Short vs. Dareus/Cox/Brockers

[methodtoll]

Here is the bigger question: How does Star compare to Suh and Ngata when they came out?

[DaCityKats]

no way can i put star over marcel.if he was the better prospect he would have have went higher.

 

 

[scarface]

If we took Dareus, we wouldnt have Cam.

If we took Cox, we wouldnt have Kuechly.

 

 

[carolina-chuck]

no way can i put star over marcel.if he was the better prospect he would have have went higher.

Dareus was a very good prospect coming out. I'm not taking anything away from him, but if Star had came out of Alabama instead of Utah he would've been a top 5 pick. And the reason why Star fell that far "again" was due to the early OLINE run.

[carolina-chuck]

If we took Dareus, we wouldnt have Cam.

If we took Cox, we wouldnt have Kuechly.

I never said we took them, did I?

I said "please" compare Star and Short to the previous high DT prospects that came out. What don't you guys get?

[carolina-chuck]

Here is the bigger question: How does Star compare to Suh and Ngata when they came out?

I think Suh has all of them beat.

Think Star is in the same comparison with Ngata.

[TheRumGone]

Huh? I'm being serious. Every time you create a thread you get defensive if someone questions you.

Just take a deep breath, you will be alright.

 

Don't question chucks opinion Red. Last time i said Star needed a rotation to stay fresh since he played 92% of snaps at Utah, he told me that I said Star was fat and needed to loose weight. He has no reading comprehension.

[La Pantera]

Dareus was a very good prospect coming out. I'm not taking anything away from him, but if Star had came out of Alabama instead of Utah he would've been a top 5 pick. And the reason why Star fell that far "again" was due to the early OLINE run.

Heart issue hurt a lot too.

[carolina-chuck]

Don't question chucks opinion Red. Last time i said Star needed a rotation to stay fresh since he played 92% of snaps at Utah, he told me that I said Star was fat and needed to loose weight. He has no reading comprehension.

That's exactly what you meant to say.

But please stay on topic

[TheRumGone]

That's exactly what you meant to say.

But please stay on topic

 

I've always been nice to you Chuck, you are the Jon Gruden of the Huddle. Take my word for what it is.

[DaCityKats]

Dareus was a very good prospect coming out. I'm not taking anything away from him, but if Star had came out of Alabama instead of Utah he would've been a top 5 pick. And the reason why Star fell that far "again" was due to the early OLINE run.

 

if that was the case, Luke (Texas A&M)would have went before Eric(Central Michigan). even tho teams went on an OL run, several teams who had needs at DT still did not pick him, including a team that that drafted a DT right before the panthers. i am glad we got him, but he is not a better prospect then Dareus.

 

[Swaggasaurus]

Short has more potential as a pass rusher than all of the others

[TheRed]

Don't question chucks opinion Red. Last time i said Star needed a rotation to stay fresh since he played 92% of snaps at Utah, he told me that I said Star was fat and needed to loose weight. He has no reading comprehension.

Chuck is an ok dude, but unfortunately his homer glasses are not at all removable.

[TheRumGone]

Chuck is an ok dude, but unfortunately his homer glasses are not at all removable.

 

I agree. I don't know why he twisted my words and called me out.