Would You Trade A 1st Rounder For Victor Cruz?

[La Pantera]

a 1st for Cruz..... No. Larry Fitzgerald/AJ Green/Calvin Johnson/ Brandon Marshal. Yes, for them a 1st

That is basically asking if we would be willing to trade Star Lotulelei for him. I say no

Hell, Marshall was traded for 2 3rds. Cruz is nowhere near worth a 1st.

[InnocentBystander]

DWILL AND A 1ST.  YEP.

[Dpantherman]

Josina Anderson ‏@JosinaAnderson2m

Victor Cruz to me this morning, "I'm going to sign my tender today and will continue talks for a long-term deal before camp starts." #Giants

 

 

[mbarbour21]

I like goin for nicks next year and keepin our first pick. Cruz seems like he might be wanting a high price. We could grab a second tight end and an o-lineman in next years draft with first two picks that way.

[Kakarot]

No 1st for Cruz, and would rather have Nicks.  My main thing with Cruz is he rarely lines up on the outside.  I would like for my #1 to play mostly on the outside, and not the slot.  With that being said, I don't think Nicks is leaving NY.  NY is going to choose Nicks over Cruz.

[Peppers90 NC]

he may be worth a first but not worth a first plus a huge outrageous contract

[Red Zone]

I'm hoping for this. I'd rather have nicks, tbh.

 

This

[YOLO!]

Hakeem Nicks will be the guy we target next year, if we have have to give up a 1rd or 2nd pick to get him we should do it.

[TheMaulClaw]

A 1st for an undrafted guy......who'd win that deal?

So I guess someone could have just offered us a 3rd for Smitty when he was in his prime at that would have been fair deal.  Let's trade a 7th for Brady, that's fair too.   Dumb logic bro.

[TheMaulClaw]

A 1st for an undrafted guy......who'd win that deal?

So I guess someone could have just offered us a 3rd for Smitty when he was in his prime and that would have been fair deal.  Let's trade a 7th for Brady, that's fair too.   Dumb logic bro.

[PiratePanther189]

Very few players are worth a first round pick.

[L-TownCat]

Im gonna have to go with no, and take my chances on getting Nicks via FA.

[Dpantherman]

You guys didn't read my post did you? He isn't going anywhere so its a moot point now.

 

Unless this is strictly a hypothetical thread. In that case, carry on.

[La Pantera]

So I guess someone could have just offered us a 3rd for Smitty when he was in his prime and that would have been fair deal. Let's trade a 7th for Brady, that's fair too. Dumb logic bro.

Dumb logic??? Ok, Brandon Marshall is a true #1 WR and he was traded for two 3rd rounders. So yeah, trading your 1st for a slot reciever (not even #1 on his team) is Dumb. Giants placed a 1st round tender on Cruz because they knew nobody would touch it. And if someone DID, they'd get a 1st for nothing. No one in their right mind would make that trade. And it has nothing to do wether he was drafted or not....BRO!!!