Would You Trade A 1st Rounder For Victor Cruz?

[MrPickles]

I'm hoping for this. I'd rather have nicks, tbh.

Me too. Cruz is a good player but he's not elite. A little overrated from playing in NY.

[Lilsmitty09]

A 1st for an undrafted guy......who'd win that deal?

Or...

A Jamarcus Russel for a top ten wideout. Could go both ways...1st rounders aren't gaurentees

[La Pantera]

Scheftner reported back in feb. that NYG would make Nicks the top priority over Cruz.

[TheRed]

He isn't worth a first and a fat contract. I doubt he leaves NY anyway.

[La Pantera]

Or...

A Jamarcus Russel for a top ten wideout. Could go both ways...1st rounders aren't gaurentees

Point being, that tbe Giants know nobodys coming off a first for him. If someone did they'd probably let him go. Great return for nothing. Ill ask the same question as earlier. When was the last time a WR was traded for a 1st?

[rayzor]

Me too. Cruz is a good player but he's not elite. A little overrated from playing in NY.

and from playing across from nicks, eli's real go to guy.

[Catalyst]

A 1st for Cruz is fair, IMO.

[LinvilleGorge]

Scheftner reported back in feb. that NYG would make Nicks the top priority over Cruz.

Yep, and I believe it.

Cruz is very good at what he does, but it's Nicks that allows him to do it.

[rodeo]

It fully depends on the WR class next year. If we end up picking in the 15-25 range, as I'd expect, is there a WR there who will be better than Cruz for the next 5 years?

[Panthro]

Cruz - 1st round pick AND big salary

It's a double whammy peoples

[Carl Spackler]

[XClown1986]

Hell... no...

[Mvp2014]

No way. I would do a 3rd.

[rayzor]

Cruz - 1st round pick AND big salary

It's a double whammy peoples

this.

 

that contract by itself is enough to make me balk. 

 

first round by itself wouldn't be horrible. first round and that contract together make me want to run away. we can find better and cheaper options.... when you consider that better receivers are being traded for  3rd and later picks and the amount of money being given out in this market is really low.