Would You Trade A 1st Rounder For Victor Cruz?

[Paige]

with him having problems getting a deal done in nyg got me thinking maybe Gettlemen who should know him really well could somehow make a deal with them and bring him here?

 

I would do it in a heartbeat not only will that give our #2 for this season but Cruz could take over as #1 once Smitty is done.

 

Our WR AFTER Deal

#1WR:Smitty

#2wr Cruz

#3:Lafell/Hixon

 

 

[Jackofalltrades]

I'd trade a second and a later pick.

[Nicbsbll2]

I'd do it in a heart beat. 

 

New York, however, would not. 

[Paige]

If we could get him without giving up a first that would be a flat out steal!

I'd trade a second and a later pick.

 

[La Pantera]

A 1st for an undrafted guy......who'd win that deal?

[Wolfcop]

I don't think we are that desperate yet. I would not give up a 1st at this point. If Smitty were to suddenly retire I would, though. At this point I think we will have options next year. Like someone else said, maybe we use our first 2 picks next year on WRs. 

[Panthro]

If he resigns then Nicks will be a Panther next year. fact

[PhillyB]

a first? hell to the no.

[La Pantera]

If he resigns then Nicks will be a Panther next year. fact

Yeah I don't think they'll be able to keep both.

[Panthro]

I don't know. A ton of teams are gonna jump on Nicks too.

 

True but he is from Charlotte and has mentioned that he would love to play here. Make him a reasonable offer is all I am asking for and let him decide.

[carolina-chuck]

Would we have the money to sign him ?

[panther4life]

I would, because it would become a late 1st. The trickery is affording him/ willing to pay more than the Giants would to keep him. As they can match any offer we make.

 

But yes I would do it.

[Mr. Scot]

I think the days of wanton draft pick trading are over.

Don't see Gettleman making that kind of offer at all.

[Panthro]

I would, because it would become a late 1st. The trickery is affording him/ willing to pay more than the Giants would to keep him. As they can match any offer we make.

 

But yes I would do it.

 

See but we have to send a pick AND sign Cruz to a deal....not cool

 

I could maybe be ok with one or the other.

 

That is why drafting a WR or signing a FA WR like Nicks is the best course of action

 

 

BTW that 1st Marty wanted to trade away to teams in the 2nd was for Clausen ....that  netted us Cam Newton the next year. Let's not gamble like that