Rank the QBs

[dimbee]

Trent Edwards

Chad Pennington

Tom Brady

Mark Sanchez/Kellen Clemens

Joe Flacco

Carson Palmer

Derek Anderson/Brady Quinn

Ben Roethlisberger

Matt Schaub

Peyton Manning

David Garrard

Kerry Collins

Kyle Orton/Chris Simms

Matt Cassell

Jamarcus Russell/Jeff Garcia

Phillip Rivers

Tony Romo

Eli Manning

Donovan McNabb

Jason Campbell

Jay Cutler

Matthew Stafford/Daunte Culpepper

Aaron Rodgers

Tavaris Jackson/Sage Rosenfels

Matt Ryan

Jake Delhomme

Drew Brees

Josh Freeman/Brian Griese

Kurt Warner

Marc Bulger

Shane Hill/Alex Smith

Matt Hasselbeck

[TerriblePizza]

1. Peyton Manning

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Phillip Rivers

5. Ben Roethlisberger

6. Kurt Warner

7. Carson Palmer

8. Donovan McNabb

9. Eli Manning

10. Tony Romo

11. Jay Cutler

12. Aaron Rodgers

13. Matt Ryan

14. Jake Delhomme

15. Jason Campbell

16. Marc Bulger

17. Matt Cassell

18. Joe Flacco

19. Matt Hasselbeck

20. Derek Anderson/Brady Quinn

21. Matt Schaub

22. David Garrard

23. Kerry Collins

24. Trent Edwards

25. Chad Pennington

26. Mark Sanchez/Kellen Clemens

27. Jamarcus Russell/Jeff Garcia

28. Matthew Stafford/Daunte Culpepper

29. Kyle Orton/Chris Simms

30. Tavaris Jackson/Sage Rosenfels

31. Shane Hill/Alex Smith

32. Josh Freeman/Brian Griese

[rayzor]

for fantasy?

[R0CKnR0LLA]

This was fun

1. Peyton Manning

2. Tom Brady

3. Kurt Warner

4. Drew Brees

5. Carson Palmer

6. Phillip Rivers

7. Aaron Rodgers

8. Donovan McNabb

9. Ben Roethlisberger

10. Jay Cutler

11. Matt Ryan

12. Jake Delhomme

13. Tony Romo

14. Matt Hasselbeck

15. Eli Manning

16. Brady Quinn

17. Shaun Hill

18. Matt Schaub

19. Marc Bulger

20. Trent Edwards

21. Kyle Orton

22. Chad Pennington

23. Joe Flacco

24. Matt Cassell

25. Matthew Stafford

26. David Garrard

27. Jason Campbell

28. Kerry Collins

29. Mark Sanchez

30. JaMarcus Russell

31. Tarvaris Jackson

32. Josh Freeman

[frash.exe]

1. Peyton Manning

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Philip Rivers

5. Kurt Warner

6. Donovan McNabb

7. Aaron Rodgers

8. Ben Roethlisberger

9. Eli Manning

10. Carson Palmer

11. Jay Cutler

12. Matt Ryan

13. Tony Romo

14. Chad Pennington

15. Joe Flacco

16. David Garrard

17. Matt Cassell

18. Matt Schaub

19. Jake Delhomme

20. Jason Campbell

21. Matt Hasselbeck

22. Trent Edwards

23. Marc Bulger

24. Kyle Orton

25. Brady Quinn

26. Kerry Collins

27. Shaun Hill

28. JaMarcus Russell

29. Matthew Stafford

30. Tarvaris Jackson

31. Mark Sanchez

32. Josh Freeman

[dimbee]

Yeah, sorry... Shaun Hill, not Shane Hill. I didn't think that sounded right...

[Skew]

Can't agree with most picks after #5, but here are my top 5. The rest will be added later.

1. P. Manning

2. Brady

3. Roethlisberger

4. McNabb

5. Rivers

based on playoff performance.

Seeing Aaron Rodgers

Carson Palmer

Jay Cutler

Matt Ryan

Tony Romo

Chad Pennington

Joe Flacco

in the top 10 is a little disturbing.

[TerriblePizza]

It was difficult to rank some of them. Because in my opinion they were close, especially after the top 10.

BTW 1000th post!

[KillerKat]

1-12: Best tested QBs of the NFL

1.Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Donovan McNabb

4. Drew Brees

5. Ben Roethlisberger

6. Phillip Rivers

7. Carson Palmer

8. Tony Romo

9. Kurt Warner

10. Eli Manning

11. Matt Hasselbeck

12. Jay Cutler

13-20: Best of the recently tested franchise QBs ( likely to continue or improve rate of play)

13. David Garrard

14. Aaron Rodgers

15. Matt Cassell

16. Matt Ryan

17. Matt Schaub

18. Jason Campbell

19. Joe Flacco

20. Trent Edwards

21-23: Best QBs on the down side of their careers

21. Chad Pennington

22. Kerry Collins

23. Jake Delhomme

24-26: Best of the recently tested QBs (consistency an issue)

24. Derek Anderson

25. Kyle Orton

26. Shaun Hill

27: Worst QBs on the down side of their careers (better chance of bouncing back due to experience)

27. Marc Bulger

28 and 29: Worst of the tested QBs (unkown if bounce back is possible or rate of play continues)

28. Jamarcus Russell

29. Tavaris Jackson

30-32: Untested

30. Matthew Stafford

31. Josh Freeman

32. Mark Sanchez

[King Taharga]

Jay Cutler #100. That is all.

[thefuzz]

1. Brady

2. Rivers

3. Manning

4. Roethlisberger

5. Rodgers

6. Brees

7. Warner

8. McNabb

9. Pennington

10. Palmer

11. Manning

12. Hasselbeck

13. Delhomme

14. Cutler

15. Ryan

16. Schaub

17. Collins

After that is gets really convoluted...

[X-Clown]

Trent Edwards

Chad Pennington

Tom Brady

Mark Sanchez/Kellen Clemens

Joe Flacco

Carson Palmer

Derek Anderson/Brady Quinn

Ben Roethlisberger

Matt Schaub

Peyton Manning

David Garrard

Kerry Collins

Kyle Orton/Chris Simms

Matt Cassell

Jamarcus Russell/Jeff Garcia

Phillip Rivers

Tony Romo

Eli Manning

Donovan McNabb

Jason Campbell

Jay Cutler

Matthew Stafford/Daunte Culpepper

Aaron Rodgers

Tavaris Jackson/Sage Rosenfels

Matt Ryan

Jake Delhomme

Drew Brees

Josh Freeman/Brian Griese

Kurt Warner

Marc Bulger

Shane Hill/Alex Smith

Matt Hasselbeck

For a second I thought these were your rankings, but now I see that you did them by team/division.

[dimbee]

Trent Edwards teh l33t3st QB evar!!!!!!

[The Link]

1. Brady

2. Rivers

3. Manning

4. Roethlisberger

5. Rodgers

6. Brees

7. Warner

8. McNabb

9. Pennington

10. Palmer

11. Manning

12. Hasselbeck

13. Delhomme

14. Cutler

15. Ryan

16. Schaub

17. Collins

After that is gets really convoluted...

All of them are much better than Delhomme.