Dear media, please stop telling me Andrew Luck is good

[AceMan]

Luck is good for a rookie, but it's hard to like him since he's SOOOOO overrated

[teeray]

Do you discount the number of game winning drives he already has? Stats are great but winning is better. Is he overly hyped yes. Does he deserve to be in the conversation with RGIII, Wilson and Cam - absolutely.

I don't discount his game winning drives any more than I do The Golden Calf of Bristol's.

But just for fun several of those game winning drives happened with 3:00+ minutes left on the clock and the defense held those leads. A luxury other QBs have not had (ahem)

[Ken]

Anyone that says Luck's receiving corp is below average, clearly don't know what they are talking about.

[teeray]

home many excuses are you prepared to make on this?

hater

sorry it does not fit your personal agenda but the kid is a good player with a bright future ahead and a very solid rookie season behind him. no amount of your ranting changes that.

LOL. Actual schedule is an excuse?? Neato.

What is my personal agenda? The truth, facts and observations?

[Herbert The Love Bug]

same goes for RG3. Overhyped player that isn't God like everybody seems to think

[carolinarolls]

he went from gabage to the beneficiary of a good schedule in less than a page....

there is an agenda somewhere

[Kakarot]

Wilson>RGIII>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Luck

[teeray]

he went from gabage to the beneficiary of a good schedule in less than a page....

there is an agenda somewhere

They aren't mutually exclusive.

And actually I said he was garbage for 3 quarters and then came up with big plays in the 4th quarter.

Also my original OP said that he is a bottom half of the NFL QB right now. I also said that he may be good someday, but right now he is below average.

The fact that you cannot seem to process what I am actually saying over your fervor to defend Luck that if anyone has an agenda it would be you.

[LinvilleGorge]

Not sure why so many huddlers are so insecure that they have to bash every young QB not named Cam Newton. Andrew Luck is damn good.

[teeray]

Not sure why so many huddlers are so insecure that they have to bash every young QB not named Cam Newton. Andrew Luck is damn good.

I haven't bashed RG3 or Russell Wilson yet. I just don't think as highly about Andrew Luck (or Dalton for that matter).

Russell Wilson is my pick for OROY, followed by RG3. I think those two are really, really good. I worry about RG3 staying healthy long term, but when he is healthy he is a baller.

I just don't think Luck is that good right now. Especially when he was advertised as the best QB to come into the NFL since John Elway.

[Ken]

Not sure why so many huddlers are so insecure that they have to bash every young QB not named Cam Newton. Andrew Luck is damn good.

[teeray]

I'm sorry, anyone watching this game right now after watching the earlier game can't honestly say that Luck looks anywhere close to these two rookies.

[LinvilleGorge]

Luck doesn't have the OL or the running game that either of these two rookies have either. The Skins and Seahawks both have GREAT running games. The Colts running game is garbage.

[LinvilleGorge]

I'm not exactly sure what RG3 does that is so impressive as a thrower. The guy probably throws the ball over 10 yards down the field less than any other QB in the league. They keep his throws very simple and that's a big reason why he has so few INTs.