Dear media, please stop telling me Andrew Luck is good

[fieryprophet]

I've got a better one. Here are quarterbacks who have turned in a Top 100 performance, or a mere 67 rating, in my QBA metric for the 2012 season:

Peyton: 9 games

Russell Wilson: 7 games

RG3: 6 games, including the top rated performance of 89

Cam: 5 games

Ryan Tannehill: 3 games

Ryan Fitzpatrick: 2 games

Brandon Weeden: 1 game

Kevin Kolb: 1 game

Andrew Luck: nil

[fieryprophet]

fuging nice stealth edit there bro. almost had you

;)

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

Why do you think Weeden is better than Brady or Rodgers

stealth edit

[fieryprophet]

Why do you think Weeden is better than Brady or Rodgers

stealth edit

Brady: 6 games, Rodgers: 4 games

I wasn't going to go through the whole list to prove a point

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

Brady: 6 games, Rodgers: 4 games

I wasn't going to go through the whole list to prove a point

Well, what game caused Weeden to be in the top 100? Also, how do you measure your QB rankings?

IMO, Lucks better games is better than Weedens better games

http://www.nfl.com/player/andrewluck/2533031/gamelogs

http://www.nfl.com/player/brandonweeden/2532970/gamelogs

[fieryprophet]

Well, what game caused Weeden to be in the top 100? Also, how do you measure your QB rankings?

IMO, Lucks better games is better than Weedens better games

http://www.nfl.com/player/andrewluck/2533031/gamelogs

http://www.nfl.com/player/brandonweeden/2532970/gamelogs

QBA methodology is here: http://50.116.44.142/qba/about/

And Weeden's single top 100 score was 70% completion percentage, 322 yards, 2 TDs and no turnovers. Luck just missed barely out on a top 100 score with his week 2 performance at Minnesota and his performance at the Dolphins, being hurt on both occasions by his lower completion percentage, and in the second game for not turning 433 yards into more offense than two scores and for also fumbling.

[CarolinaNCSU]

Andrew Luck's face bothers me. Like, really bothers me. The idea of a girl willingly ever having sex with him, scares me.

[DaveThePanther2008]

Most of us know that Luck has been hyped for 2 yrs as the second coming of God Himself. He is the son of the greatest Pro Football Hall of Fame Snub ever!!!! Oliver Luck

While he might be better than dear ol' dad. I am not ready to start his HOF mold just yet. He had an extremely soft schedule and won 2 games against Quality opponents. Minnesota and Green Bay (Green Bay was abysmal when they played) Houston had nothing to play for in week 17. All of them were at home. 54 % completion with over 600 attempts. Sack 41 times.. and on and on.

Luck lived on the ESPN hype mobile all season long. Had RGIII or Wilson not come along his pedestrian numbers would have won him ROY just because no one wants to admit they were wrong.

Luck may have a great Career but as a rookie he was OK. Definitely not ROY worthy.