Yasinskas: WR Rankings

[tarheelpride]

http://myespn.go.com/blogs/nfcsouth/0-12-14/Ranking-the-NFC-South-wide-receivers.html

Smitty #1

[Fireball77]

Michael Clayton @ #10? I loved that kid coming out of college but after a good rookie year he hasn't done much. Yas is desperate for warm bodies if he is putting him @ 10 IMO.

[unicar15]

Michael Clayton @ #10? I loved that kid coming out of college but after a good rookie year he hasn't done much. Yas is desperate for warm bodies if he is putting him @ 10 IMO.

10 WRs out of 4 teams is going pretty deep. Most teams are lucky if they have 2 good ones which means that after #8 there are going to be reaches. He should have combined WR/TE IMO.

[thefuzz]

Agreed...and Meachum anywhere on that list is kinda funny.

[Fireball77]

10 WRs out of 4 teams is going pretty deep. Most teams are lucky if they have 2 good ones which means that after #8 there are going to be reaches. He should have combined WR/TE IMO.

Agree 100%. Great point.

[Section 505]

Smitty #1

Shocking, just shocking.

[Udogg]

I thought I wasn't going to get pass #1. If smitty wasn't #1 I was going to stop reading.

[DaCityKats]

the way they are on atlanta nuts surprised there 3 was not the 1st names on the list.espn biased.

[WilkinsonDonnie]

These ratings are all bogus. Seems like Yas may of been projecting a bit....couldn't notice. Robert Meachum better than Dwayne Jarrett, Clayton, Stovall? Heck no! Meachum hasn't done anything expect barely get on the playing field and show the signs of a bust. HORRIBLE HORRENDOUS CHOICE!

YAS you suck.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

These ratings are all bogus. Seems like Yas may of been projecting a bit....couldn't notice. Robert Meachum better than Dwayne Jarrett, Clayton, Stovall? Heck no! Meachum hasn't done anything expect barely get on the playing field and show the signs of a bust. HORRIBLE HORRENDOUS CHOICE!

YAS you suck.

Meachem had more yards last year than Jarrett has in two. Like many on this board, I'm of the opinion that Jarrett has a lot of potential and can develop into a good starter for the Panthers, but to say he's a better player than Meachem right now is laughable.

I actually think the ratings are pretty much right on. Like Unicar15 pointed out, 10 receivers from four teams is going to inevitably leave some third receivers in the mix, or some second receivers that aren't star players by any means.

I'd like to see how all of you critics rank the division's ten best receivers. I have a feeling we'd see Jason Carter up there. He does have some potential, right?

[WilkinsonDonnie]

Devery Henderson had a better year than Meachem

[Peppers90 NC]

There should be a big gap after Smitty on the list, no one deserves the #2 spot after him in this division.

[rayzor]

should have stuck to 5

[monstercat]

Jarrett's numbers would have been a lot better if we ran the same offense as the Saints and didn't use a roster spot on an extra kicker every week.