Ndamukong Suh

[Jackofalltrades]

Yes, I think his talent and impact are worth the risk.

[Carolina Fan]

Jenkins was better, he was mean without having to be dirty.

I like Suh because he is talented, i just don't think his ego would fit with this team. But who knows maybe it would.

[Carolina Husker]

All the credit Suh got his rookie year. It now seems to me that McCoy is the better of the two, and its not even close.

El Oh El

[charlotte49er]

Not many time that I EVER agree with Jason Whitlock. This maybe a first!

Ndamukong Suh should be happy there’s a debate over whether he’s a “dirty” player. If not for discussion of his controversial tactics, people would focus on the fact that he’s an average defensive lineman.

Watching Suh on the same field with Houston’s electrifying JJ Watt hammered home the point of Suh’s ineffectiveness. Watt is a master at using every tool in his toolbox. He uses his hands, his quickness, his strength, his leaping ability, his instincts, whatever. Most plays, Suh simply relies on his girth and strength. He’s very inconsistent with how he uses his hands.

Of course, Suh’s biggest play on Thanksgiving was his “accidental” kick to the groin of Houston quarterback Matt Schaub. I agree with the league that the replay of Suh’s kick was inconclusive in terms of justifying a suspension.

But all the talk surrounding the kick overshadowed Suh’s zero-tackle day. He was credited with five QB hits/pressures. Two or three of those pressures came on screen plays when Suh slipped by offensive linemen who intentionally let him slip by.

Meanwhile, JJ Watt recorded five tackles, three sacks, four tackles for loss, two passes defensed and five QB pressures.

[carolinarolls]

hell yes

4-5 of them please. Go large, biggie size it, super size, make it the combo. I'll take all that meanness. pent up aggression, raw ambition and passion to inflict pain every day of the week and TWICE every Sunday.

I don't have to like the players off the field. Like it matters if I like them or not anyway. This game was made for people who want to hurt each other until one side breaks. Contrary to what we watch every week, football was never meant to be a ballet with an oblong ball, some dance instructors with striped shirts, and a "treat everyone how you want to be treated" mantra.

Give me the biggest and the meanest and let me worry about how much leash to give them.

[DeeJay]

This team with a new GM will want to go big and fast

Thus we pick up this monster.

[SOJA]

yes

[Keep Pounding]

I would love to have Suh and watch him slam Drew Brees on his head, and then ask Brees "Do you need an explanation?"

[Riverboat Ron]

I'll take him, but only if the lions take Clausen and give us Megatron as well.

[Mr. Scot]

He's a dirty POS who flirts with legal troubles from time to time. And these days, he's not quite the unstoppable force he was early on.

Still one of the best in the league at his spot though.

I'm iffy. You could probably talk me into it, but I'd have reservations.

[carolina-chuck]

His rookie year, not now.

Suh hasn't been as dominant as his first year. Teams learned how to stop his game now. He depends too much on bull rushing and nastiness to scare opponents. He can't scare no one anymore. His knuckle head has taken over his game on and off the field. Do not want.

I want Geno Atkins! The man is so underrated. Wanted him so bad when he came out. Too bad Hurney didn't see it

[rayzor]

he'd be an upgrade in a huge way.

it'd be crazy to not get him if we had a chance.

i think a lot of the problem in detroit is that it's a lot of hotheads being coached by a hothead.

just out of curiosity, detroit's not talking about letting him go, are they?

that coach will probably be fired first. i think it's likely he's one of the coaches that gets fired this year. his team is out of control most of the time.

[mmmbeans]

Jenkins was better, he was mean without having to be dirty.

I like Suh because he is talented, i just don't think his ego would fit with this team. But who knows maybe it would.

jenkins was dirty as hell... maybe more-so than buckner and it was awesome.

[FastNFurious]

Sure....just watch out for that karate kick to the groin