Ok be honest

[DaCityKats]

who did u hate when we brougt them in? I feel like a dumbass but i hated the beason pick in the draft .... i didnt know who the hell he was. anyone else wanna come clean?

i guess you don't watch football.the U produces lbs and i hated the david carr pick up:rolleyes:

[guyinchesapeake]

I didn't like Tim McKyer. I didn't like Sean Gilbert, anyone who can claim straightfaced that God himself told him to hold out for more money (as he did with the Redskins) is not someone I want in my huddle, unless he can use his connections to shut down the other team's offense! I had no use for MeShaun Johnson. And Kevin Green as a true weenie following the '96 season, and he was more a liability than an asset when he came back.

[Fireball77]

I was pretty surprised they picked up Keyshawn as he didn't seem their type of player attitude wise, and I was a bit skeptical but I can't say I hated the pickup. And he was a contributor for sure. I would love to know the real, actual reason(s) they dumped him.

[Britneck]

Biakabutuka. How do you not take Eddie George? I wanted Eddie so bad. When Tim actually played you could see why they picked him, but still a awful pick.

[X-Clown]

Weinke. Probably the most overrated Panther in history by the fans.

[bLACKpANTHER]

Weinke. Probably the most overrated Panther in history by the fans.

who ever overrated Weinke..

[PeteRozelle]

I was just waiting for someone to take a shot at Fox.

he said be honest.....

[scpanther22]

Vinnie- pointless

i dont think it was pointless D-will has said he gives vinnie credit for the talks and help he gave him to work hard to be a great RB..

[Britneck]

Yeah. Weinke was drafted in the fourth. I was happy about that pick. You don't get much in the 4th and we took a shot. It didn't work out, oh well.

[thefuzz]

I was pretty surprised they picked up Keyshawn as he didn't seem their type of player attitude wise, and I was a bit skeptical but I can't say I hated the pickup. And he was a contributor for sure. I would love to know the real, actual reason(s) they dumped him.

I have always been pretty confused about letting Key go...you would think that it would have come out by now. Maybe he just really sucked in the locker room like everyone suggested.

[X-Clown]

who ever overrated Weinke..

A lot of fans. Do you remember all the calls for him to start after the Detroit game in 2005?

Yeah. Weinke was drafted in the fourth. I was happy about that pick. You don't get much in the 4th and we took a shot. It didn't work out, oh well.

I agree with that for people who saw him for what he was, a 4th round pick with no pocket presence and limited upside. However, a number of Panther fans looked at the Heisman trophy and believed the training camp buzz about how strong his arm was and yadda yadda.

[Snake]

A lot of fans. Do you remember all the calls for him to start after the Detroit game in 2005?

I agree with that for people who saw him for what he was, a 4th round pick with no pocket presence and limited upside. However, a number of Panther fans looked at the Heisman trophy and believed the training camp buzz about how strong his arm was and yadda yadda.

It was sad when people were calling for Weinke to start over Delhomme but hey those where the same people wanting Carr to push Delhomme for starter.

[dexterpyro]

George Seifert.......i know he isnt a player but WTH happened???

Thought he won b/c of the system he learned, not that he was a good coach

Plus i thought Dom needed one more year.....

[Britneck]

A lot of fans. Do you remember all the calls for him to start after the Detroit game in 2005?

I agree with that for people who saw him for what he was, a 4th round pick with no pocket presence and limited upside. However, a number of Panther fans looked at the Heisman trophy and believed the training camp buzz about how strong his arm was and yadda yadda.

Yeah i miss read what you said. I had in my head what the thread was about. My bad. I agree 100% with your original statement.