if RR is out and...

[King Taharqa]

Reid is overrated. Still living off McNabb, hasnt won a playoff game since him. Phillys O line is terrible, Vick gets hit IN THe POCKET more than any QB, and Reid wont utilize their best offensive weapon in MCCoy. He would only ruin Cam, no thanks. We need a HC who isnt afraid to run the ball.

[lightsout]

It's only an upgrade in the sense of instead of having a nail in our ass, it'll be a tack.

[Gabeking]

# of Super Bowl Rings

Andy Reid- 0

Ron Rivera- 1

Now STFU

Ron Rivera is a poo poo coach though

How is that even relevant?? Ron Rivera was DC not a HC, two totally different jobs there.

[csx]

# of Super Bowl Rings

Andy Reid- 0

Ron Rivera- 1

Now STFU

Ron Rivera is a poo poo coach though

Reid got a ring coachng with Green Bay.

[4Corners]

Reid is overrated. Still living off McNabb, hasnt won a playoff game since him. Phillys O line is terrible, Vick gets hit IN THe POCKET more than any QB, and Reid wont utilize their best offensive weapon in MCCoy. He would only ruin Cam, no thanks. We need a HC who isnt afraid to run the ball.

These are good points as well in an argument against hiring Reid.

Like I said, I'm not politicking for Reid here but I do honestly think that if it looks like both teams are going to make a change (and it looks that way right now!) ESPN and the media trolls are going to be all over this calling it a "perfect fit" for a team that needs a HC, GM, and Cam babysitter.

[csx]

How is that even relevant?? Ron Rivera was DC not a HC, two totally different jobs there.

Ron got one as a player. He never won a ring as a coordinator.

[Mr. Scot]

The Eagles have had a solid organization, good ownership, strong scouting, shrewd free agent strategy, great cap management, etc. etc. and even with all of that behind him, Reid still hasn't been able to bring home a Super Bowl trophy.

What makes people think he can do it with the Panthers organization?

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

# of Super Bowl Rings

Andy Reid- 0

Ron Rivera- 1

Now STFU

Ron Rivera is a poo poo coach though

wat

Reid got a ring when he was the OC with Green Bay in the 90s

Rivera got one from being a bench warmer and coddling dikta's and singletary's balls in 85

[4Corners]

The Eagles have had a solid organization, good ownership, strong scouting, great cap management, etc. etc. and even with all of that behind him, Reid still hasn't been able to bring home a Super Bowl trophy.

What makes people think he can do it with the Panthers organization?

Yeah another solid argument against Reid. If anything, Reid has proven he CANT win a super bowl when everything else around him is in good shape.

[Snake]

Dont want Reid. IMO he never really developed McNabb and he does not seem to be helping Vick all that much either. If we are going offensive minded coach I would say Chip Kelly would fit the bill.

[4Corners]

I don't understand the love affair with Chip Kelly, either. IMHO, they've got to get a guy that's an NFL coach now.

[Carolina Husker]

Reid has basically already taken the San Diego job.

[Jackofalltrades]

It wouldn't take much to upgrade this mess, however I have little to no interest in Reid.

[Snake]

I don't understand the love affair with Chip Kelly, either. IMHO, they've got to get a guy that's an NFL coach now.

No love affair, but I would rather have a offensive Guru and a winner over a guy that rode the coattail of a Philly defense for so many years.