Name the 10 players that would hurt us the most if not on the team next year.

[KasayKickz]

jeeezzz...why don't we keep the whole team?

tee hee. you make a good point, and while the 1-5 record sucks, I want to wait till the end of the season to formulate a full opinion. For all I know, someone like Josh Thomas could end up being an awesome cornerback all of a sudden. Or Geoff Hangartner could be exposed as a horrible offensive lineman.

If things keep going like they have been (which I do not think will happen) that list is going to be a whole lot smaller.

[megadeth078]

tee hee. you make a good point, and while the 1-5 record sucks, I want to wait till the end of the season to formulate a full opinion. For all I know, someone like Josh Thomas could end up being an awesome cornerback all of a sudden. Or Geoff Hangartner could be exposed as a horrible offensive lineman.

[Jackofalltrades]

I'll play:

Stew

Kalil

Gross

Smith

J Anderson

CJ

D Edwards

Kuechly

TD

Gamble

Alexander

[Icege]

Jonathan Stewart

Ryan Kalil

Luke Kuechly

Jordan Gross

Steve Smith

Greg Olsen

John Beason

Frank Alexander

Amini Silatolu

Charles Johnson

Not saying that any of them are irreplaceable, but they're solid players that contribute.

[Happy Panther]

LUUUUUUUKKKKKEEEEEE!!!!!!!

[megadeth078]

I think it's funny that people think Smith is so much more important than Lafell.

How do you include one but not the other?

[PantherPhann89]

Smith

Kalil

Gross

Kuechly

Stewart

Jensen

LaFell

Davis

[C47]

Jonathan Stewart

Ryan Kalil

Luke Kuechly

Chris Gamble (more because he's the only DB worth a damn right now)

Byron Bell

Greg Olsen

Steve Smith

Charles Johnson (same as Gamble)

Frank Alexander

Thomas Davis

James Anderson

[cbully]

Some people are over reacting:

Gross

Kalil

Cam

Bell

Olsen

Stewart

Johnson

Keuchly

Gamble

Davis

All are top ten in their respective positions.

I think we could upgrade from Gamble! very overrated and weak tackler

[Snake]

LaFell

Dwill

Stew

Gross

Kalil

Bell

Olson

Keek

Davis

Gamble

[Wyank]

In fire the coaches threads, we say we have talent just bad play calling on offense and coaching on defense.

In get rid of player threads, we say we have no talent and hard to find even 10 players worth keeping.

[davos]

O:

Stewart

Kalil (even though he's injured, he's a good one to have)

Olsen

D:

Kuechly

Alexander

Davis

[KasayKickz]

I think there is a ton of talent on this roster, but in a depth capacity. We have guys that would be very strong rotational or situational players. If we can move some of the bad bad contracts (big IF) and fix our needs via free agency and the draft I see no reason why we can't contend for a playoff spot next year.

Assuming we ditch the read option.

[Marguide]

In fire the coaches threads, we say we have talent just bad play calling on offense and coaching on defense.

In get rid of player threads, we say we have no talent and hard to find even 10 players worth keeping.

The truth probably lies somewhere in the middle. I think we have enough talent to be a close to .500 team, but we don't have enough in the right places to get us where we want to go.