Steve Smith for Lee Evans straight up

[Nu Guns]

He still is pretty damn good and I think he deserves to be on that list.

[SCpanther]

Any WR list that doesn't have Smith in the top 5 is illegitimate.

[bigdog_10_2002]

Braylon Edwards, Lee Evans, Greg Jennings, above smith is absolutely comical

[faultlessjoint]

was the OP serious?

I'm being super cereal, you guys.

[Mr. Scot]

Part of the reasoning in the SI post behind ranking Evans higher than Smith was that he'll be across from Owens. The author expects Owens to get the lion's share of attention from the defense, thus allowing Evans to have a "breakout".

Trade Evans away from the Bills and that goes out the window.

[CatMan72]

Owens is washed up, so the logic behind ranking Evans higher is bogus. How big of a season did Roy Williams have with Owens playing across from him?

[monstercat]

Owens is washed up, so the logic behind ranking Evans higher is bogus. How big of a season did Roy Williams have with Owens playing across from him?

Good point.

[DOUBLETROUBLE28]

this is the dumbast thread ever

[ChucktownK]

I'd do it in a heartbeat. I mean just look at what SportingNews has to say:

http://www.sportingnews.com/yourturn/viewtopic.php?t=548492

How about straight up your ass...

maybe you'll locate your head too.

[d-run]

I think it's funny that they rated 8-5 over Housh. Housh had a way better year last year than Johnson, and they brushed aside Johnson's bad year by saying he didn't have Palmer throwing to him. Weird

[beastson]

Everybody above Smith is not better than Smith, except arguably Fitz

Wow my football knowledge just dropped a few points after seeing that

[pepaw]

I'm being super cereal, you guys.

super cereal:lol:

[Easyt65]

That is a horrible list.

The only pick I agree with is Fitz.

The idea of Smith for Evans, IMO - no disrespect intended - moronic. I would not trade Smith For Fitz, either. Fitz's game against us was huge because we did not blitz and Fox allowed Fitz to mandate/choose his own coverage all night.

Nuff said!

[X-Clown]

The idea of Smith for Evans, IMO - no disrespect intended - moronic. I would not trade Smith For Fitz, either. Fitz's game against us was huge because we did not blitz and Fox allowed Fitz to mandate/choose his own coverage all night.

Nuff said!

Fitz had big games against teams other than us. Fitz also will turn 26 this year and Smitty just turned 30.