Name 1 cut that turned out to be a bad decision(op updated with responses)

[SZ James (banned)]

The first reply pretty much nails it (some other good ones as well) and sh*ts all over your theory. McClain might turn out to be the right decision but you totally went about the wrong way to come to that conclusion.

There's no saving this thread we're done here.

[GreatPoupon]

tony brown, jarret bush, rashard butler?

[Doc Holiday]

Tony brown, the guy was a beast all through training camp and preseason and then he goes to the titans and starts for a long time on a pretty good defense

[Doc Holiday]

tony brown, jarret bush, rashard butler?

Naw man bush was just ok, he's the nickle back for green bay not even starting

[pantherclaw]

Witherspoon. We didn't cut him but the dude was a beast and is still now. TDavis was drafted to replace him. Davis is good but I think if I have to choose, I'd choose Witherspoon over Davis.

anderson was drafted to replace spoon.

But don't let the facts get in the way.

[pantherclaw]

we paid spoon's money to morgan, so essentially we cut him

nobody said anything about training camp

spoon turned down a contract. Morgans contract had nothing to do with spoon leaving for more money.

[pantherclaw]

Mathis, haye, and brown were nothing resembling starters when they left here. Derek Landri on the other hand had started some and played fairly well and could have been kept around for something resembling the minimum at a positon of need. That one kind of bugs me.

I agree with Landri.

[Vampire the buffet slayer]

I can name at least one thread that turned out to be a bad decision.

[Brooklyn Bully]

ALTERNATIVE QUESTION...

Have we ever signed anyone else's trash that's amounted to a hill of beans here?

[Vampire the buffet slayer]

Jake Delhomme?

[SuperMan]

He slipped past 2 other teams as well.

We gave him 3 years,the bengals gave him 3 and then he finally clicked with the eagles. Giving a player 6 years to develop is a little much.

Six is a stretch he was a very good player for the Bengals they just did not want to pay him.

[carolina-chuck]

anderson was drafted to replace spoon.

But don't let the facts get in the way.

Are you sure? If I remember correctly, Davis was drafted as a Safety to play LB the year after Spoon left. Anderson was a third rounder, I think? I wouldn't consider that as replacing Spoon.

[TANTRIC-NINJA]

So 1...

OP has it right, not a Jarrett, Everette Brown, Keary Colbert, Damone Lewis have come back to haunt the Panthers. Not even Keyshawn Johnson!

Jovan Haye? Ok he is solid.. But..

[MadHatter]

Evan Mathis, pro-bowl guard.

Agree with this one.