Name 1 cut that turned out to be a bad decision(op updated with responses)

[Firefox]

Moose WAS cut.

2/25/05

http://www.panthers.com/team/roster/muhsin-muhammad/25d579c3-79f5-44de-83a6-e58eeca4ced3/

[carolina-chuck]

Witherspoon. We didn't cut him but the dude was a beast and is still now. TDavis was drafted to replace him. Davis is good but I think if I have to choose, I'd choose Witherspoon over Davis.

[Dingo_ate_Babies]

Took him 4 years before he got to that levee after cut him. He slipped past 2 other teams as well.

We gave him 3 years,the bengals gave him 3 and then he finally clicked with the eagles. Giving a player 6 years to develop is a little much.

Wrong again.

"Mathis played for the Cincinnati Bengals from 2008–2010. He did not allow a sack during the 2009 and 2010 seasons"

[Porn Shop Clerk]

we paid spoon's money to morgan, so essentially we cut him

nobody said anything about training camp

[KissMyConverse]

In all honesty I agree with the intent of the thread. We haven't really shot ourselves in the foot in the past and I don't think we did it this time as well.

That being said if we had only kept Moose....

[CRA]

In all honesty I agree with the intent of the thread. We haven't really shot ourselves in the foot in the past and I don't think we did it this time as well.

That being said if we had only kept Moose....

Yeah, Moose....

The one time Hurney needed to overpay someone....he didn't.

[XClown1986]

John Kasay, tony brown, jarrett bush,

[panther4life]

Jovan Haye DT ended up starting for bucs and played well against us.

Tony Brown and Jovan Hayte off the top of my head. Both went elsewhere and contributed much more than they did here.

We had Jenkins and Carstens at 3-tech when Haye left. Carstens was better that year and actually produced 4 sacks.

Brown left when we had Jenkins Damione Lewis and Carstens ahead of Brown at 3-tech the year we cut him.

[Jackofalltrades]

Sean Gilbert.

[Firefox]

David Akers

[Shlomo]

Keyshawn Johnson, only because the man that was supposed to be his successor was absolute dog poo. I think Key still had a couple good years left in him when he retired

[panther4life]

Wrong again.

"Mathis played for the Cincinnati Bengals from 2008–2010. He did not allow a sack during the 2009 and 2010 seasons"

He had a whopping 7 starts over 3 years with the Bengals. in 08 and 10 he didn't have one start!

Its amazing how you can avoid allowing a sack when you don't play

http://www.nfl.com/p...418/careerstats

[2jakefansinva]

Sean Gilbert.

please...............never mention that name again.

[XClown1986]

We had Jenkins and Carstens at 3-tech when Haye left. Carstens was better that year and actually produced 4 sacks.

Brown left when we had Jenkins Damione Lewis and Carstens ahead of Brown at 3-tech the year we cut him.

Whats your point? Tony Brown should have been kept based on what happened to the players we kept. Id say it qualifies as a cut that haunted us or wasn't the right choice.