Jason Smith @ Nfl.com (Cam A Top Ten Qb)

[La Pantera]

Romo sucked ass! He's got to be the most overhyped QB. He chokes more than 5$ whowar.

[top dawg]

I agree with that, but ranking Big Ben over Rodgers and Brees is insane...

Not really. This isn't out of the realm of possibility. Plus, Big Ben has 1 more ring. With an O-line, Ben is as scary as any QB in the NFL.

[Borat]

The fact that Stafford trails Vick and Matty is absurd. And Ben's ranking? Absolutely nuts.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

The fact that Stafford trails Vick and Matty is absurd. And Ben's ranking? Absolutely nuts.

that's why "wins" and "titles" is a dumb ass metric for judging quarterbacks. that should be used as a cop-out tiebreaker when you're comparing two enormously great quarterbacks at the very most.

i mean, it's true that you'd be hard pressed to find two quarterbacks with better resumes than eli and ben over the last several seasons-five super bowl appearances and four rings between them. now, would you take either over drew brees and his one appearance and one ring?

[Mage]

Romo sucked ass! He's got to be the most overhyped QB. He chokes more than 5$ whowar.

Right, which explains why he had 4 4th quarter comebacks last season, would have had 6 not his kicker sucked. Also explains why he had one of the highest passer ratings in the 4th quarter last season.

Romo is criminally underrated simply because some only like to listen to the media and others hate the Cowboys. Come on. Romo completed 66% of his throws, threw for 31 touchdowns to only 10 interceptions, and had a 100+ QB rating. But he's not in the top ten or he sucks?

I don't even get how people can say he is overhyped when all the media talks about is how he might be replaced.

[La Pantera]

1-6 in the playoffs, the only stat you need to know about Romo. ;)

Jets, lions ,giant and he has thrown 17 4th quarter ints..I can dig deeper if you want. The guy can't win when I counts.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

i think people are still clinging to the media coverage romo got in 2006/2007 coupled with how bad our losses to them in those years stung. that and a lot of fans in the carolinas just naturally hate the cowboys.

none of the cowboys fans i know really like him, oddly.

[Peppers90 NC]

Stafford should be higher than Matt Ryan.

Eli is not the best QB in the league. Yeah he won 2 SB but the defense helped alot.

Dalton should be higher than 17th

My top 10

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Drew Brees

3. Ben Roethlisberger

4. Payton Manning (if healthy)

5. Eli Manning

6. Cam Newton

7. Matthew Stafford

8. Phillip Rivers

9. Michael Vick

10. Matt Schaub (But needs to stay healthy)

whoa, no brady?

[La Pantera]

I haven't met many cowboys fans that are happy with him. If the boys don't make a big playoff push this year, Jerry Will find his replacement.

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

saw eli at 1

X'd out

just because he put Cam in the top 10 doesnt mean this is a good list. also im not even sure if cam is top 10, but the Cam Defense Force will take it personally if i i say anymore, so yeah

[Fiz]

Hey pff let's rank QBs by their passing shall we?

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

Hey pff let's rank QBs by their passing shall we?

I'd rather rank by wins and Super Bowl's. Cool stats don't get you that jewelry.

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

To me...

1. Tom Brady

2. Aaron Rogers

3. Eli Manning

4. Drew Brees

5. Peyton Manning

6. Ben Roethlisberger

The rest is a crap shoot.

[Fiz]

I'd rather rank by wins and Super Bowl's. Cool stats don't get you that jewelry.

4 of the top 5 in those cool stats have lots of wins and superbowls!