Best Back-Up Qb In Nfc South?

[SuperMan]

i heard anderson has a wet noodle as an arm, not so sure about that deep ball comment.

You must be deaf, by all accounts DA has a cannon.

http://washington.sc...c=1&nid=1126498

http://sportsillustr...yers/64307.html

and here is a scouting report on Ryan Mallet comparing his arm strength with Anderson's. (aka a strong arm)

http://walterfootball.com/scoutingreport2011rmallett.php

and have you ever seen him throw?

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

For those that keep mentioning Josh Johnson. HE'S ON THE 49ERS!!!

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

Here is how I rank the quarterbacks in our division (Yes I know I did all of them)

1. Drew Brees (New Orleans)

2. Cam Newton (Carolina)

3. Matt Ryan (Atlanta)

4. Josh Freeman (Tampa Bay)

5. Chris Redman (Atlanta)

6. Derek Anderson (Carolina)

7. Dan Orlovsky (Tampa Bay)

8. Chase Daniel (New Orleans)

9. Jimmy Clausen (Carolina)

10. Brett Ratliff (Tampa Bay)

11. John Parker Wilson (Atlanta)

12. Dominique Davis (Atlanta)

13. Sean Canfield (New Orleans)

[nickzz]

Remember that PP21 is a pro bowl corner.

no, he is a pro-bowl return man.

[panthernation23]

You must be deaf, by all accounts DA has a cannon.

http://washington.sc...c=1&nid=1126498

http://sportsillustr...yers/64307.html

and here is a scouting report on Ryan Mallet comparing his arm strength with Anderson's. (aka a strong arm)

http://walterfootbal...011rmallett.php

and have you ever seen him throw?

scouting reports on him coming out of college saying he has a "live arm" doesn't mean anything. I think the question is have YOU ever seen him play in a brown uniform. I have, and i can tell you the fact is that he does not have a "cannon" for an arm.

[panthers34]

anderson is good with chud at oc

[Hate]

Chris Redman

[SuperMan]

scouting reports on him coming out of college saying he has a "live arm" doesn't mean anything. I think the question is have YOU ever seen him play in a brown uniform. I have, and i can tell you the fact is that he does not have a "cannon" for an arm.

I have my old man is a life long browns fan, he has a strong arm, you need your vision checked.

[panthernation23]

I have my old man is a life long browns fan, he has a strong arm, you need your vision checked.

go watch the preseason games last year, compare cam's throws to anderson's. Cam has a cannon for an arm, Anderson is nowhere close to that velocity. This is why every one of anderson throw's was in the 10 yard range.

[DOMOMAN]

go watch the preseason games last year, compare cam's throws to anderson's. Cam has a cannon for an arm, Anderson is nowhere close to that velocity. This is why every one of anderson throw's was in the 10 yard range.

Quick Release ≠ Arm Strength.. Anderson throws a bomb deep, but he has a long windup, he can't zip it like Cam but he can chug it down pretty far if give time

[PantherPhann89]

I'd go with Derek Anderson for the following reasons:

* He's our backup QB

* He's a our Pro Bowl backup QB

* He knows our system better than any QB on our roster

* He has experience against ~ every defense in the NFL

[SuperMan]

go watch the preseason games last year, compare cam's throws to anderson's. Cam has a cannon for an arm, Anderson is nowhere close to that velocity. This is why every one of anderson throw's was in the 10 yard range.

Cam has one of the strongest arms in the league top 5 easily, Anderson has a strong arm not a top 5 arm, this entire argument started because you said he had a wet noodle, if you want a wet noodle go look at some of Chad Pennington's throws.

Also his throws being 10 yard throws probably had something to do with it being preseason think about it.

[Herbert The Love Bug]

Anderson has also failed miserably.

Sad to say he still might be the best. NFC South might have the best starters, but it severely lacks depth at the QB position.

uh well yeah, that's usually how it works. Teams with really good starting QBs usually don't have great back ups because they really aren't needed.

[L-TownCat]

Drew Brees