Jonanthan Stewart or Joe Flacco? If you had hindsight.

[Squirrel]

You never thought Slaton would have that good of a year though, be honest. IIRC before the draft, you were pretty skeptical of his ability to succeed in the NFL. That said, he was great. I liked watching him run. I think he fits well in Hou.

But your premise I can get behind, OL in the first, RB in the second. A lot of people thought that (esp w/Forte in 2nd). I wonder if they had had a first rounder this year, woud they have taken Brown with it?

I wonder also who would pick on Carolina for going RB and RB in the first with only a few years in between now that Indy just did pretty much the same thing.

Oh your right I thought for sure Slaton would be a bust but this is hindsight so I can say Slaton now.

[Porn Shop Clerk]

Offensive picks in the 2nd round always bomb for us.

[dpanthersman]

isnt that wat flacco did in baltimore... helloooooo, thats the only thing that made me think of this thread lol

i said that becaue someone mentioned franchise QB> franchise RB in a post before. helloooo

[Zod]

can we skip the hindsight for last year and go straight to the Eric Shelton pick instead?

[SorthNarolina]

Stewart is a speed guy as well... Dude can fly. Not sure what your point was. lol

however, to answer the question, Stewart all day long... It's rare to find a guy with his speed and size and character and talent...

i honestly think stewart is faster than williams, i don't know if he'll bulk up more this season but last season he looked faster

[mantal]

Oh your right I thought for sure Slaton would be a bust but this is hindsight so I can say Slaton now.

Good response...

[RSXNova]

Stewart would have been the 1 and only option for some team and he would have been RoTY

[bleys]

i honestly think Stewart is faster than Williams, i don't know if he'll bulk up more this season but last season he looked faster

I would take that bet...

[CM86]

stewart single handily won at least a couple of games for us (one off the top of my head was that chicago game). i'd take j-stew everyday.

[Porn Shop Clerk]

can we skip the hindsight for last year and go straight to the Eric Shelton pick instead?

And numerous 2nd round WRs that didn't pan out. But Shelton is what I was thinking about specifically.

[SCP]

Easy....... I'd take Johnathan Stewart.

[mantal]

Jonathan Stewart got close to 1000 yards as a number two back. How is this even a question? Fox could put on a uni and play QB handing off the ball and it would still be a formidable offense...

[CM86]

Jonathan Stewart got close to 1000 yards as a number two back. How is this even a question? Fox could put on a uni and play QB handing off the ball and it would still be a formidable offense...

which begs the question, why did we stop running the ball against AZ?! :frown2:

[nosuchthingasapanther]

this would be a tough decision, if from day one flacco could have the same chemistry with smith that delhomme does...but going off the fact that no other panther QB has been able to do it, stewart hands down.

stewart had just as much or more of an impact with carolina as a #2 as all the other starting rookie RB that were drafted after him did with their respective teams.