The Best/worst Of Marty Hurney

[Guest Irv]

Would you rather have hurney? or tannenbaum the jets gm that extended sanchez and traded for The Golden Calf of Bristol?

[R0CKnR0LLA]

Would you rather have hurney? or tannenbaum the jets gm that extended sanchez and traded for The Golden Calf of Bristol?

i wouldnt want anything to do with tannenbaum but even so the jets have a better record under him than we have under hurney

[PhillyB]

wherever he stands, he will hang his hat on whatever happens with cam. he will be remembered, good or bad, by what happens over the next couple of years. if he can successfully build a team around cam newton - and i think he will - that'll be his legacy.

[Pimpdaddy]

.... my favorite subject, bashing Hurney (and Peppers). If your mantra is build thru the draft he gets a D+. Hes the reason why we are in the situation we are in and why we are scrabbling to shore up SP and D. Oh, and who is going to be catching passes if Gettis and LaFell aren't the deal. I think Chico can pull a rabbit out his @ss in spite of Marty.

[top dawg]

He's ok at drafting..

terrible FA moves. aside from Stephen Davis. I can't remember one good FA move

Lucas was probably his best move. I'd say 7 out of 10...maybe a 6 (other than Davis, of course).

Not too good.

[Snake]

Drafting Cam, when everybody was beating down his door to say what a stupid idea it was, is enough for me. He got the quarterback right. People heap praise on the Patriots all the time, but they draft pretty badly, let good players walk, and make bad trades/FA pick ups all the time. They just got the quarterback right and that's enough to overcome everything else.

QB and Coach right.

[Snake]

Yeah, I do believe Hurney is in the same position as Fox was. Progression needs to happen for him to stay another two years. But I think Cam would save his ass if we won the Superbowl in that time. I guess we will see how he works the contracts, because that's what is going to hurt the Panthers, not talent. We do have one of the best cores in the NFL. and with a 2nd year QB. :cam:

He does what Richardson tells him to do so I think his job is safe. The real question is when is Richardson going to stop this all or bust thing in FA.