Question for everyone

[carpanfan96]

With all the moaning and groaning going on about Delhomme getting the Extension, I figured I'd ask a question.

If we signed a qb right now with the guarantee of winning the superbowl this season, but for the next 15 years we would average 3 - 4 wins a season. Would you do it?

1 great season with a ring for 15 years of being dreadful record wise.

[Fox007]

Huh? How often does that happen.

Make it a Dynasty first, then 15 years of 4 wins and you got yourself a deal.

[carpanfan96]

I was just hypothesizing, to my knowledge it doesn't happen. We don't know what's going to happen next season, jake could have his best year next season and us get back to the super bowl or we could go 6 - 10 or worse. The deal is Just one ring for 15 years of crap. Would you take the deal (kinda a deal with the devil for your soul type thing). Would the ring be worth it?

[Fox007]

I was just hypothesizing, to my knowledge it doesn't happen. We don't know what's going to happen next season, jake could have his best year next season and us get back to the super bowl or we could go 6 - 10 or worse. The deal is Just one ring for 15 years of crap. Would you take the deal (kinda a deal with the devil for your soul type thing). Would the ring be worth it?

I guess I would have to know what would happen in those 15 years if I didn't take the free 1 SB.

I mean, by what you said, we get 1 free SB, and 15 years of sh*t.

But during that 15 if we don't take the deal we may get one anyway and have winning seasons in others.(or 2 or so SB's)

[carpanfan96]

You don't know what's going to happen in those 15 years, we could win a sb or two, but then again we might not win any. I was just bringing it up because of all the hoopla over us getting another QB for this season, since Jake sucks so much.

[Squirrel]

Hell no! 1 guareented Superbowl for 15 years of sucking never.

[carpanfan96]

Option two.

Two Super Bowls back to back for 18 years of crap.

[Fox007]

I wouldn't do it, because I'd rather earn it.(or them earn it) But that's how I am.

[guyinchesapeake]

It's a bad premise. If I KNEW we'd win a SB, then suck for all that time, I'd sell my PSLs. Why support someone you know sucks? It's like being an Obama supporter...

OK, I threw that in there just to throw a bomb. It won't happen again. I think it's the wine...I'm sorry...Please, don't tell Michelle...or Bo!

[Nu Guns]

Heres a better question:

If we had home field advantage in a the playoff game and our "TOP 11" QB turned the ball over 6 times would you reward him 20 million dollars?

[Lone Buc Fan]

The Panthers haven't even got one ring in 13 seasons... Might aswell take the trade off for the ring as it could be another 15 or longer before you guys even win one.

[Nu Guns]

Buc....you have no room to talk.

How long did it take the Bucs to get that ring

[Lone Buc Fan]

Fact is, they still won a ring. I'm saying with these options, you guys should just take the guaranteed ring as the Panthers are nowhere near being the best team in the NFL this season or until Jake is gone (5 years right there)

[Jangler]