American Idol 2012

[g5jamz]

Good show last night.

Still think Hollie and Joshua are the strongest.

Jermaine Jones kicked off show due to law enforcement issues. Geez...and we lose someone that really deserved it over this guy. Shame.

[Inimicus]

Pretty bored with it all this season so far.

Joshua's performance last night was about the only thing that's been worth the time Ive put in thus far.

[Kramerica]

Anyone else surprised with how open they were about his criminal history? They could've just said something like "for personal reasons Jermaine had to withdraw from the competition" but instead they made a scene of it. Just seemed kind of wrong to me and they could've been a lot classier about handling it. Butthurt because he lied to them maybe?

The performances were decent. I like how the judges are being more tough--now we might really see people step it up.

[g5jamz]

The way "issues" have been handled in the past made for insane conspiracy theories, rumors, and overshadowed the show at times. He had outstanding warrants and they needed that to be out there...and remember...this is reality tv and anything to get a dramatic pause is what it's all about. Gentile giant screwed over David Leathers.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Joshua Ledet is honestly the only reason to watch this anymore.

I like Phillip, Heejun, and Elise a lot, but they're inconsistent. Joshua has killed it every week.

I don't care too much for the rest. DeAndre and Skylar are likable, and the rest are pretty boring/generic.

This Jessica Sanchez hype is super annoying too. She's not THAT good.

[Dpantherman]

Josh really does remind me of Fantasia and if he dominates every week like she did, he'll sail into the final.

Hated the song DeAndre sang

[sunbunny]

Curly boy sucked last night. Love his hair, though. I still like Colten and Phillip. I think Jessica IS that good.

The tall blonde 16 year old has blown it two weeks in a row. She should go next.

My husband loves that country chick. Can't remember her name. The extra country one.

[g5jamz]

I do NOT like Reba-sounding singing (although I like Reba as a person...she was awesome in Tremors), but this chick was awesome.

http://www.americanidol.com/videos/season_11/performances/skylar_laine_wind_beneath_my_wings/

[Dpantherman]

I guess I'm alone as a DeAndre fan, I think hes unique. Joshua is a great singer, but I wish he would mix it up.

-I wasn't a big fan of Jessica or the other girl they stood up for.

[g5jamz]

I don't get the DeAndre thing. Falsetto only gets you so far.

[Kramerica]

Josh really does remind me of Fantasia and if he dominates every week like she did, he'll sail into the final.

Hated the song DeAndre sang

Said the exact same thing last night to my girlfriend about Josh. And I can't stand DeAndre normally, but last night he was better. At least he mixed up the regular voice and falsetto a little bit. Still wouldn't buy his record, but he'll hang around another week.

[Dpantherman]

I dig DeAndre though, because thats kind of music i like listening to. Big fan of Maxwell, Eric Benet, Debarge, etc...which is kind of who he is comparable to.

[sunbunny]

The only one who impressed me last night was Skylar (is that the country chick's name?) Holy mother of god there's something in the vent. I just saw it moving and it furry. It stuck something through the register and I dont' know if it was tail, face, foot, something.

[g5jamz]

Deandre gone...Elise is gone next if she does a repeat.