Pat White in the second round for Panthers?

[King Taharqa]

That's funny, because I'm pretty sure on the old board that you said Michael Vick is a better quarterback than Matt Ryan. In fact, you cited that Matt Ryan hasn't gotten his team to the NFC Championship (even though he was a rookie) and that Vick has. Again, which is it?

Mike Vick isnt an awesome QB, but he's better than most on this board give him credit for and he's better than Matt Ryan and you can quote me again on that. Mike Vick takes his team to an NFCG, gives defenses headaches for 5 years, beats us 6 times, and he's garbage. Matt Ryan simply just makes the playoffs and wins ROY (like Vince Young, hmmm) and he's suddenly the annointed one. LOL.

Like I said, if Pat White plays defensive tackle or defensive end, and can play it well, draft him at #59. Like I also said, it doesn't matter who our quarterback is if our defense continues to give up points by the bushel. Hopefully the Meeks hiring fixes it, we shall see.

D tackle or D End is the safe pick. Playing it "safe" hasnt brought any rings to Carolina yet. And the All World D-End you already have doesnt want to be here anymore partly because he doesnt believe in the QB you already have now. Replacing his production with a first year player is no more a given than us getting a young mobile QB to enhance our offensive ball control.

[Kurb]

I actually would be pretty excited if we drafted White.

[Fox007]

Reason to give him a shot. But Im like some other people if we dont get some earlier picks I dont want us grabbinga QB first.

BOWL OPP RESULT CMP ATT YDS CMP% LNG TD INT RAT ATT YDS AVG LNG TD

MEINEKE CAR CARE BOWL @North Carolina W 31-30 26 32 332 81.3 44 3 1 193.09 21 55 2.6 16 0

TOSTITOS FIESTA BOWL AT GLENDALE AZ @Oklahoma W 48-28 10 19 176 52.6 9.26 79 2 0 0 119.6 20 150 7.5 42 0

GATOR BOWL AT JACKSONVILLE FL Georgia Tech W 38-35 9 15 131 60.0 8.73 57 2 0 1 128.1 22 145 6.6 27 1

Nokia Sugar Bowl @Georgia W 38-35 11 14 120 78.6 8.57 30 1 0 2 126.2 24 77 3.2 13 0

Well there is no guarantee that any defensive player we pick would do anything anyway.

Like you posted, at least PW is a proven winner, and has a bunch of experience.

There is no right or wrong as long as who/what we get works out for us in the long term.

[Fox007]

D tackle or D End is the safe pick. Playing it "safe" hasnt brought any rings to Carolina yet. And the All World D-End you already have doesnt want to be here anymore partly because he doesnt believe in the QB you already have now. Replacing his production with a first year player is no more a given than us getting a young mobile QB to enhance our offensive ball control.

DT is NEVER a safe pick, they don't transition well to the pros, and have just as high a bust rate as QB's.

They are comparable to how long it takes for a WR to transition.

[mantal]

Mike Vick isnt an awesome QB, but he's better than most on this board give him credit for and he's better than Matt Ryan and you can quote me again on that. Mike Vick takes his team to an NFCG, gives defenses headaches for 5 years, beats us 6 times, and he's garbage. Matt Ryan simply just makes the playoffs and wins ROY (like Vince Young, hmmm) and he's suddenly the annointed one. LOL.

D tackle or D End is the safe pick. Playing it "safe" hasnt brought any rings to Carolina yet. And the All World D-End you already have doesnt want to be here anymore partly because he doesnt believe in the QB you already have now. Replacing his production with a first year player is no more a given than us getting a young mobile QB to enhance our offensive ball control.

So who are you a fan of since you use the third person to refer to the Panthers? Kinda trollish to me...

[King Taharqa]

Of course.

That's not what KT said...he said huge upgrade immediately.

Do you really believe we cant get a QB in here who can throw more than 15 TDs next year? Do you really believe that Pat White's ability to extend plays and sustain drives wouldnt be valuable to our offense? Do you really believe Pat White would not energize this fanbase? Jersey sales, upside, national attention, etc, its a no brainer!

[goodlay]

Pat White = Reggie Bush. He can do everything except play his actual position.

[King Taharqa]

Pat White = Reggie Bush. He can do everything except play his actual position.

How does a QB who cant play his position win 5 bowl games?

[tarheelblue89]

Pat White = Reggie Bush. He can do everything except play his actual position.

Hes one of the best College QBs of all time. He can play his actual position if he is given the chance to.

[Squirrel]

How does a QB who cant play his position win 5 bowl games?

4 bowl games but we get your point. As Pat White has the leadership you want in a QB. Never gives up, A role model in the community and calm under pressure.

[goodlay]

Hes one of the best College QBs of all time. He can play his actual position if he is given the chance to.

College success doesn't translate into NFL success.

[King Taharqa]

4 bowl games but we get your point. As Pat White has the leadership you want in a QB. Never gives up, A role model in the community and calm under pressure.

5 including the Senior Bowl.

[Panthro]

I'd love White if we got a 1st and 2nd for Pepps....though I think he needs a year or two in the league to become a successful NFL QB

[Squirrel]

5 including the Senior Bowl.

Touche'