Smitty comeback player of the year?

[Carolina Fan]

Can anyone think of anyone who would get it over Smith?

[Lumps]

Romo

[PhillyB]

Romo? :lol: what's the story, he came back from perennially sucking and sucked?

[PantherBoy95]

Bitch don't steal what you saw me mention in another thread lol.

(Alex Smith has a great case when you think about it...if his play matches their record)

[Dex]

Reggie Bush...

But seriously if it doesn't go to Smitty I will be mad.

[chef17]

Romo? :lol: what's the story, he came back from perennially sucking and sucked?

66 completion %, 8 yard avg, 4000 yards, 32 TDs, 13 turnovers is considered sucking?

[La Pantera]

Alex smith will win it.

[The_Cannon]

Stafford

[jtnc]

Stafford.

[Dilla]

Alex Smith, probably.

[Jangler]

loud noises

[Double Trouble]

maybe marshawn lynch too, lots of choices out there. hope smith wins though.

[Panths]

The Golden Calf of Bristol. He should win everything.

[Brooklyn Bully]

Stafford.

I think Smitty is a tough sell. HE didn't have a lack of PERFORMANCE last season. His QBs did. He won it in 2005 due to the broken leg the year before. That's why Stafford gets it, IMO. Had Smitty had Cam, for example, last year and Cam had thrown for 4000 yds but Smitty didn't do jack. Then the next year went all out he'd make the case.