You knew it was coming

[BigSyke]

naw need a defense. this guy build a one man team lol. part of the reason is manning didnt want anyone to threaten his position....

[Mvp2014]

I'm no Hurney fan but hell no

[rayzor]

hurney isn't the perfect GM by any means, but still hurney >>>>>>> the douche that is polian.

polian's place in history is very overrated...esp. in regards to panthers history.

[csx]

Tempted to fire Hurney and bring back Bill Polian if he'd come?

Of course I don't think JR would...but I would "think" about it.

No, I'm not. I don't have the power to. You should ask Richardson.

[B.BERSIN]

you are fuging stupid and keep posting like a idiot

[Mr. Scot]

Anyone thinking Bill Polian would fit here again needs to brush up on their history.

Polian and Jerry Richardson did not mesh together at all. The two of them had a huge personality clash. And when Polian ultimately left, Jerry wasn't exactly teary-eyed at his departure.

Even if our GM job was open right now, Polian would not be a candidate.

[carolinarolls]

hurney drafted newton, williams, stewart.

polian drafted collins, biakabutuka, carruth.

hurney drafted eric shelton, keary colbert, everette brown, dewayne jarrett

make an argument that isn't immediately dismissed based on obvious cherry-picking and fact skewing next time.

[PhillyB]

hurney drafted eric shelton, keary colbert, everette brown, dewayne jarrett

make an argument that isn't immediately dismissed based on obvious cherry-picking and fact skewing next time.

are those your four best cherries?

[davos]

Anyone thinking this is an idiot. Polian will most likely be working for ESPN and Chris will end up somewhere...maybe even with Brian in Stanford.

...and anyone who continues to trash the Polians are pieces of sh*t who have no respect for the game and look the the Peyton situation as his only smart move. Get over his time in Carolina and remove the foot from thine asshole. They are actually quite stand up people so stfu about this "Polians are garbage" crap.

[Jase]

hurney drafted eric shelton, keary colbert, everette brown, dewayne jarrett

make an argument that isn't immediately dismissed based on obvious cherry-picking and fact skewing next time.

Who me?

I would never.

and leave skew out of this.

[davos]

Hell no and Polian burned his bridges here.

He and his kids are garbage.

This is unenlightened garbage

[carolinarolls]

are those your four best cherries?

off the top of my head just to make a point. why?

[rayzor]

Anyone thinking Bill Polian would fit here again needs to brush up on their history.

Polian and Jerry Richardson did not mesh together at all. The two of them had a huge personality clash. And when Polian ultimately left, Jerry wasn't exactly teary-eyed at his departure.

Even if our GM job was open right now, Polian would not be a candidate.

polian's personality clashes with most people, esp. his bosses.

[davos]

polian's personality clashes with most people, esp. his bosses.

If people want to know the actual situation:

Irsay wanted his team back bottom line. Polian had appointed Chris to GM without much consulting, pissed off a good deal of the fan base, and along with that kept in the FO acting like he was the owner. its because Irsay is a soft soft guy who until this past week did next to nothing within that organization. Bill is an owner in disguise as a GM which requires working for an owner like Irsay. Irsay saw this as an opportunity to get his team back and did just so.

BTW, don't be surprised if Peyton is propped up into management starting next year with Irsay becoming a GM/Owner a la Jerry Jones for a season or 2 but I'm not making a declaration other than yep...Peyton is actually done playing.