Should dome QBs have an asterisk by their season stats?

[rayzor]

nope. just penalized....you know, only counting for 80% or something.

or just an asterisk beside their name stating that most of their games were played pussy style...indoors. that would suffice.

when brady passes the marino it will be a whole lot more impressive, imo. none of their games were played indoors this year.

[rayzor]

how bad does that have to sound that tom brady plays the game tougher than your mole-faced hero QB?

[ed bell]

Tons of rain and wind? He had to fight that on occassion, but not that often.

Division rivals were Buffalo, NY Jets, Baltimore and New England....all outdoors and except for home games all in the Northeast.

No asterisk needed but NO has played outside just 5 times all year and only once since October 16th....a close shave against Tenn.

[Ruff]

Actually, when the season ends, Brees will have played in ten dome games.

I absolutely believe that it should be noted that he achieved it while playing a majority of his games indoors.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

How do you guys not see that Zod's trolling?

[Urrymonster]

How has Brees done outdoors? If the performances are similar, this is essentially a pointless exercise.

[Chaos]

lol

Curtis Painter needs one too.

[rayzor]

How do you guys not see that Zod's trolling?

unpossible that he's the only one here doing it. lol

[CPF4LIFE]

How has Brees done outdoors? If the performances are similar, this is essentially a pointless exercise.

All his bad games have been outdoors, but thats only been like 2 this year.

[Ruff]

As of now, Brees has 9 TDs and 6 INTs in outside games.

[Davidson Deac II]

Division rivals were Buffalo, NY Jets, Baltimore and New England....all outdoors and except for home games all in the Northeast.

No asterisk needed but NO has played outside just 5 times all year and only once since October 16th....a close shave against Tenn.

True, but each qb has certain advantages and disadvantages based on location, schedule, era etc... Marino for example played in an era in which the AFC was generally much weaker than the NFC, especially on the defensive side. Would he have set the record had he played in the NFC east? It was at that time the best division in football. It can also be argued that any qb that plays in cities like Chicago and Buffalo are at a tremendous disadvantage. For that matter, maybe all qb's this year should have an asterisk beside their name since qb's in years past faced tougher defenses.

[ElkinPanthersFan]

Would still take the Greatest Show on Turf or NE's 2007 offense over the Taints.

[PhillyB]

they should have asterisks on internet message board stat compilations but that's it.

[Panthercougar68]

I don't mean to take away from Drew's accomplishment and I fully congratulate him on it but I'm just not impressed since today's offenses are all pass heavy. Marino had the record with 362 completions on 564 attempts while Brees has 440 completions of 622 attempts. You're bound to break records when you basically pass every play.