Should dome QBs have an asterisk by their season stats?

[MadHatter]

No more than having....

QB's of pass oriented teams with an asterick

RB's of run oriented teams with an asterick

Sorry Zod....not one of your best attempts.

[Urrymonster]

Not sticking up for Scarface, but they use the short passing game as an extension of the run game. Shorter yards per pass.

Aware of this, but my point was, if Green Bay wanted that record, they could of broken it easily.

[Donald LaFell]

It's no coincidence that Newton is breaking a rookie yardage record and Brees is breaking the all-time yardage record. The lockout is what helped. Seems crazy to say but the lockout affected defenses more than offenses.

[D34Williams]

What an awful, awful thread

[thefuzz]

IMO, no.

However I would prefer to play all games outside.

[rayzor]

how could anyone not believe that playing more than half their games indoors didn't help their passing numbers?

no wind. no rain. constant temperature.

:lol:

looking at their history, it's pretty sad that they've been playing in that dome for so long and still managed to suck for so many decades. they have a 5-7 record in the playoffs. 5 playoff wins ever...in 40 years and the only ones they managed to win were indoors.

[Doyle]

Are we going to put an asterik by the dome kickers and receivers as well? :rolleyes:

[rayzor]

Are we going to put an asterik by the dome kickers and receivers as well? :rolleyes:

i already do..esp. dome kickers.

[L-TownCat]

I say yes to all of the dome QB's except Manning, i think he would be just as effective anywhere. It took Drew Brees a long time to find his stride with only one good season outdoors.

[TruCatzFan]

This is ridiculous. NO they won't and shouldn't get asterisks.

Never seen so many Haters in my life!

[thefuzz]

Play the game like it was supposed to be played.

[Carolina Fan]

Should they? no

is it an advantage? yes but unless they play every single game in a dome i don't think it really counts.

[rayzor]

This is ridiculous. NO they won't and shouldn't get asterisks.

Never seen so many Haters in my life!

Should they? no

is it an advantage? yes but unless they play every single game in a dome i don't think it really counts.

if they play more than half their games inside protected from the elements while most of their competitors don't...then they absolutely should have a qualifier.

they have an advantage for most of their games that other teams and QBs do not that makes their job easier.

[TruCatzFan]

if they play more than half their games inside protected from the elements while most of their competitors don't...then they absolutely should have a qualifier.

they have an advantage for most of their games that other teams and QBs do not that makes their job easier.

You're right.... I guess that means that all stats from any dome game should be wiped from the record books<------- Do you see how retarded that sounds??