NFLN Proclaims Newton The Greatest Rookie Ever

[nickzz]

Not really debating what you said, but just adding some footnotes.

I think its quite fitting for one of the greatest college prospects having to be the encore or the punchline of what most are now considering the greatest rookie season ever. Especially given the history of the Panthers and the pursuit of Luck.

they'll be comparing his rookie season next year to cam's

[Donald LaFell]

Nobody is butt hurt here son. Come this weekend i'll watch my guy Dalton play his way into the playoffs (if he can) against one of the best defenses in football. Andy has had an amazing season both in stats and wins. While your boy Cam will be playing for.....what exactly? Maybe next year.

Rookie of the Year is an award given to an individual. Wins are not the stats of an individual. This is the same argument people used to cover up The Golden Calf of Bristol's problems. Now it's being used to supplement the lesser accomplishments of Dalton when compared to Newton.

[bauss]

Nobody is butt hurt here son. Come this weekend i'll watch my guy Dalton play his way into the playoffs (if he can) against one of the best defenses in football. Andy has had an amazing season both in stats and wins. While your boy Cam will be playing for.....what exactly? Maybe next year.

Last I looked there's 53 guys on a team. Teams make playoffs, not players as individuals.

Nobody here is saying Dalton hasn't had a good rookie season. However, Cam's has been one of the best rookie seasons ever. It's not even debatable. no matter how many times you want to downplay Cam's achievements by throwing a playoff card out there.

[Grammer]

lol at you dumbasses who are shitting on luck... the decision was made nearly a year ago and your vaginas still hurt? get a fuging grip