NFLN Proclaims Newton The Greatest Rookie Ever

[Donald LaFell]

Oh yeah bases on what i've seen he could be blessed with greatness. but i don't live in the future i live in the now.

What has he done in "the now" that leaves doubt? He's been improving all season along with his teammates and he just had the best game of his career.

You're just being skeptical for the hell of it. You either like playing devil's advocate or you just don't like Cam Newton. He's deserving of high praise as is the entire team.

[YoungPanthers89]

redskins fan;dr

[Jesse]

http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/standings;_ylt=AipYL3MdShVH.U4F4P6MC3JDubYF

All that really matters baby

Not for an individual award based on performance of that one person.

So are you a Carolina fan or what? You obviously like to argue everything on the board and if that turns you on cool, but why?

[GritsRgreat]

What has he done in "the now" that leaves doubt? He's been improving all season along with his teammates and he just had the best game of his career.

You're just being skeptical for the hell of it. You either like playing devil's advocate or you just don't like Cam Newton. He's deserving of high praise as is the entire team.

As i said before and on many occasions i want the Panthers to win. Cam has had a wonderful season stats wise and deserves praise for it. I wouldn't have posted here but for the fact that my name was called up. Dalton was my favorite QB in the draft (I'm not saying the Panthers should have drafted him with the 1st pick) and to see him doing so well does my heart warm. He's a great kid and beating the Ravens is a tall task but i was right about his skills and leadership and i hope for nothing but the best.

[PanthaSan]

what the fug does when luck enters the nfl have to do with what it?

who?

[bleys]

As i said before and on many occasions i want the Panthers to win. Cam has had a wonderful season stats wise and deserves praise for it. I wouldn't have posted here but for the fact that my name was called up. Dalton was my favorite QB in the draft (I'm not saying the Panthers should have drafted him with the 1st pick) and to see him doing so well does my heart warm. He's a great kid and beating the Ravens is a tall task but i was right about his skills and leadership and i hope for nothing but the best.

that's fine and all.. I'm listening to Skip Baylis come from the same place.. you thought Dalton would be a solid QB, you were right, so you want to hold that accuracy above other examples..

Cam still wins ROY hands down..

[bauss]

DicksRScrumptious likes to channel his Newton hate by the stats of other QB's, since of course all the pre-draft hate is completely debunked. Now the stats are so god awfully lopsided to Cam's favor it's time to pull the "oh such and such is going to the playoffs" card.

GTFO you butt-hurt Bitch. Nobody cares about the Redskins here.

[carolinarolls]

http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/standings;_ylt=AipYL3MdShVH.U4F4P6MC3JDubYF

All that really matters baby

In a discussion about the greatest Rookie ever?

OK :rolleyes:

Well maybe they would have been better off keeping Palmer and using the Dalton pick elsewhere...

:eek:As if they had a choice --lmao@U !!

I think you need a break dewd

[nickzz]

everyone who thinks cam isn't the ROTY is stupid

/thread

[GritsRgreat]

DicksRScrumptious likes to channel his Newton hate by the stats of other QB's, since of course all the pre-draft hate is completely debunked. Now the stats are so god awfully lopsided to Cam's favor it's time to pull the "oh such and such is going to the playoffs" card.

GTFO you butt-hurt Bitch. Nobody cares about the Redskins here.

Nobody is butt hurt here son. Come this weekend i'll watch my guy Dalton play his way into the playoffs (if he can) against one of the best defenses in football. Andy has had an amazing season both in stats and wins. While your boy Cam will be playing for.....what exactly? Maybe next year.

[bleys]

- Tom Brady: 5,006 yards of total offense, 39 total touchdowns, 13 total turnovers

- Drew Brees: 4,872 yards of total offense, 38 total touchdowns, 12 total turnovers

- Cam Newton: 4,567 yards of total offense, 34 total touchdowns, 16 total turnovers

- Andy Dalton: 3301 yards of total offense, 21 total touchdowns, 15 total turnovers

1 is more like the other 2.. the other one is named Andy Dalton.. by win of unanimous votes: Cameron Newton easily wins ROY.

[mav1234]

I've heard and read every Luck hype from those on ESPN and NFLN and PFT, a site backed by NBC Sports.

hype is not the same as saying "best rookie QB ever." Those sites are saying he is one of the best prospects ever. You'll notice some of those articles, even one by ESPN's Mel Kiper, also notes people like Andre Ware and Ryan Leaf among his "best prospects ever." Because they are prospects, and there is still time for them to fail or succeed.

Everything points to Luck having a shot at a good career but until he proves it on the field, nothing is certain. Just because ESPN is enthralled with him as a prospect doesn't mean they think he is undoubtedly going to blow away Cam or something.

[nickzz]

Nobody is butt hurt here son. Come this weekend i'll watch my guy Dalton play his way into the playoffs (if he can) against one of the best defenses in football. Andy has had an amazing season both in stats and wins. While your boy Cam will be playing for.....what exactly? Maybe next year.

andy dalton simply willed his team into playoff contention

[bauss]

hype is not the same as saying "best rookie QB ever." Those sites are saying he is one of the best prospects ever. You'll notice some of those articles, even one by ESPN's Mel Kiper, also notes people like Andre Ware and Ryan Leaf among his "best prospects ever." Because they are prospects, and there is still time for them to fail or succeed.

Everything points to Luck having a shot at a good career but until he proves it on the field, nothing is certain. Just because ESPN is enthralled with him as a prospect doesn't mean they think he is undoubtedly going to blow away Cam or something.

Not really debating what you said, but just adding some footnotes.

I think its quite fitting for one of the greatest college prospects having to be the encore or the punchline of what most are now considering the greatest rookie season ever. Especially given the history of the Panthers and the pursuit of Luck.