Why Is Armanti Edwards Still Returning Punts?

[SnarkAttack]

he's a garbage player and if we murdered every piece of poo who went to that joke of a "university" the world would be a better place

i can't imagine what would breed this kind of hate for App. St. It's a mid-major...

[YourMomsLover]

he's a garbage player and if we murdered every piece of poo who went to that joke of a "university" the world would be a better place

Really? Thats pretty fuged up. You are apparently drunk.

I hope everyone that went to your community college gets murdered as well.

[YourMomsLover]

With that said...he should be our 3rd string QB.

Give me a reason he shouldnt be.

People said Cam wouldnt pan out either...whadda ya fugin know!?!? Including me.

[The_Mango55]

They're trying to see if he has any value at all to this team. I personally think you keep him on as the third QB and release Pickles, at least he has some skill however slight.

Totally agree.

Only keep 2 QB's on the roster and keep Edwards on as a reciever, ST player and emergency/wildcat QB.

[YourMomsLover]

Totally agree.

Only keep 2 QB's on the roster and keep Edwards on as a reciever, ST player and emergency/wildcat QB.

Agreed as well...

Either 3rd QB, or wildcat only. No returns.

[JawnyBlaze]

33nd pick is like a late first imo

252nd overall is like a REALLY late first imo

[bleys]

I gave him benefit of a doubt early on this year.. but dude will be cut as soon as the season is over.

[cbarrier90]

he's a garbage player and if we murdered every piece of poo who went to that joke of a "university" the world would be a better place

Nice to know you think my death would make the world a better place...you, sir, have some hate in your heart you need to get rid of, ASAP.

As far as AE is concerned, he's had the right attitude and I do believe he has worked hard, but with as many opportunities as he's had this season, it's obvious the experiment just isn't working. I see no way at all he makes the team next season, and to be honest, it would be best for all parties involved.

[The_Mango55]

Nice to know you think my death would make the world a better place...you, sir, have some hate in your heart you need to get rid of, ASAP.

Well you've got to remember his name is "Keith Moon's Liver" which tells us several things:

1: He's british, so that gives him a bitter inferiority complex to begin with

2: He's not functioning correctly

and 3: He's spent a lot of time inside another man...

[LinvilleGorge]

I facepalmed when we made that trade and then drafted Armanti, but I hoped for the best. The guy was a phenom at App State. No doubt about it.

Unfortunately, at this point, it's pretty clear that it's not gonna work out. He better make some huge strides this offseason or he'll be looking for a job next season.

To be clear, I don't blame it on him. It's on Hurney. Hurney drafted the guy to play a position he hadn't played since he dabbled there in HS. That's a big risk move, not a move you trade a future #2 to try. Armanti should've been a late round draft pick that was looked at as a potential move to WR or a wildcat QB. He's a guy who was probably bound for the CFL as a QB and very well may could've had a very successful career there as a QB. Now, due to our investment and stubborness, he's going to be years removed from playing that position too. I think he could've been a great CFL QB. Nothing wrong with that.

[CarolinaKat]

I'm glad none of you run an NFL team. None of you Madden arm chair general mangers know what it takes to be an NFL player.

Personally I have no problem keeping Edwards. He may not be averaging big numbers but he isnt muffing punts or fumbling the ball either. And when they do actaully block for him he has had some nice returns.

Edwards has a better chance of being on this team next year than Clausen. Now how many could have predicted that

[bleys]

I'm glad none of you run an NFL team. None of you Madden arm chair general mangers know what it takes to be an NFL player.

Personally I have no problem keeping Edwards. He may not be averaging big numbers but he isnt muffing punts or fumbling the ball either. And when they do actaully block for him he has had some nice returns.

Edwards has a better chance of being on this team next year than Clausen. Now how many could have predicted that

if you want to settle for a guy to just catch a punt and sacrifice any attempt at better field position, then yeah, Armanti is your guy.

I like to hope our coaching staff isn't going to settle for mediocrity and will try to find a player who can play at the NFL level.. Your right, not many can do it. But you're wrong, only those who can get to have a job.

[Khyber53]

The first job of any punt returner is to catch the ball. Advancing the ball upfield is purely secondary.

He's doing well enough.

[Carolina Fan]

Its Armantis fault that he got drafted where he did, Its his fault this is the first year hes returned punts.

And it really his his fault hes never muffed a punt, and made HUGE strides during the off season in the WR position

so i agree because of what we gave up to get him he doesn't deserve time to develop, that would be asinine.